1932
0
  1. Home
  2. A-Z Publications
  3. Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics
  4. Volume 56, 2018
  5. Article

Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics

Volume 56, 2018

Multiple Stellar Populations in Globular Clusters

Abstract

Globular clusters (GCs) exhibit star-to-star variations in specific elements (e.g., He, C, N, O, Na, Al) that bear the hallmark of high-temperature H-burning. These abundance variations can be observed spectroscopically and also photometrically, with the appropriate choice of filters, due to the changing of spectral features within the band pass. This phenomenon is observed in nearly all of the ancient GCs, although, to date, it has not been found in any massive cluster younger than 2 Gyr. Many scenarios have been suggested to explain this phenomenon, with most invoking multiple epochs of star formation within the cluster; however, all have failed to reproduce various key observations, in particular when a global view of the GC population is taken. We review the state of current observations and outline the successes and failures of each of the main proposed models. The traditional idea of using the stellar ejecta from a first generation of stars to form a second generation of stars, while conceptually straightforward, has failed to reproduce an increasing number of observational constraints. We conclude that the puzzle of multiple populations remains unsolved, hence alternative theories are needed.

Keyword(s): color-magnitude diagram, stellar abundances
Loading

Article metrics loading...

/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-astro-081817-051839
2018-09-14
2024-04-16
Loading full text...

Full text loading...

/deliver/fulltext/astro/56/1/annurev-astro-081817-051839.html?itemId=/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-astro-081817-051839&mimeType=html&fmt=ahah

Literature Cited

  1. Anderson J, Piotto G, King IR, Bedin LR, Guhathakurta P 2009. Ap. J. Lett. 697:L58–62
  2. Bailin J, Harris WE 2009. Ap. J. 695:1082–93
  3. Bastian N, Cabrera-Ziri I, Davies B, Larsen SS 2013.a MNRAS 436:2852–63
  4. Bastian N, Cabrera-Ziri I, Niederhofer F et al. 2017. MNRAS 465:4795–99
  5. Bastian N, Cabrera-Ziri I, Salaris M 2015. MNRAS 449:3333–46
  6. Bastian N, de Mink SE 2009. MNRAS 398:L11–15
  7. Bastian N, Hollyhead K, Cabrera-Ziri I 2014. MNRAS 445:378–84
  8. Bastian N, Lamers HJGLM, de Mink SE et al. 2013.b MNRAS 436:2398–411
  9. Bastian N, Lardo C 2015. MNRAS 453:357–64
  10. Bedin LR, Piotto G, Anderson J et al. 2004. Ap. J. Lett. 605:L125–28
  11. Behr BB 2003. Ap. J. Suppl. 149:67–99
  12. Bekki K 2017. MNRAS 467:1857–73
  13. Bekki K, Campbell SW, Lattanzio JC, Norris JE 2007. MNRAS 377:335–51
  14. Bekki K, Freeman KC 2003. MNRAS 346:L11–15
  15. Bell RA, Dickens RJ 1980. Ap. J. 242:657–72
  16. Bellazzini M, Bragaglia A, Carretta E et al. 2012. Astron. Astrophys. 538:A18
  17. Bellini A, Bedin LR, Piotto G et al. 2010. Astron. J. 140:631–41
  18. Bellini A, Piotto G, Milone AP et al. 2013. Ap. J. 765:32
  19. Bellini A, Vesperini E, Piotto G et al. 2015. Ap. J. Lett. 810:L13
  20. Bertelli G, Nasi E, Girardi L et al. 2003. Astron. J. 125:770–84
  21. Bragaglia A, Carretta E, D'Orazi V et al. 2017. Astron. Astrophys. 607:44–61
  22. Bragaglia A, Carretta E, Gratton R et al. 2010.a Astron. Astrophys. 519:A60
  23. Bragaglia A, Carretta E, Gratton RG et al. 2010.b Ap. J. Lett. 720:L41–45
  24. Bragaglia A, Gratton RG, Carretta E et al. 2012. Astron. Astrophys. 548:A122
  25. Brandt TD, Huang CX 2015. Ap. J. 807:25
  26. Briley MM, Cohen JG, Stetson PB 2004. Astron. J. 127:1579–87
  27. Cabrera-Ziri I, Bastian N, Davies B et al. 2014. MNRAS 441:2754–59
  28. Cabrera-Ziri I, Bastian N, Hilker M et al. 2016.a MNRAS 457:809–21
  29. Cabrera-Ziri I, Bastian N, Longmore SN et al. 2015. MNRAS 448:2224–31
  30. Cabrera-Ziri I, Lardo C, Davies B et al. 2016.b MNRAS 460:1869–75
  31. Çalışkan Ş, Christlieb N, Grebel EK 2012. Astron. Astrophys. 537:A83
  32. Caloi V, D'Antona F 2007. Astron. Astrophys. 463:949–55
  33. Cameron AGW, Fowler WA 1971. Ap. J. 164:111
  34. Cannon RD, Croke BFW, Bell RA, Hesser JE, Stathakis RA 1998. MNRAS 298:601–24
  35. Carretta E 2014. Ap. J. Lett. 795:L28
  36. Carretta E 2015. Ap. J. 810:148
  37. Carretta E, Bragaglia A, Gratton R, Lucatello S 2009.a Astron. Astrophys. 505:139–55
  38. Carretta E, Bragaglia A, Gratton RG et al. 2006. Astron. Astrophys. 450:523–33
  39. Carretta E, Bragaglia A, Gratton RG et al. 2010.a Ap. J. Lett. 714:L7–11
  40. Carretta E, Bragaglia A, Gratton RG et al. 2009.b Astron. Astrophys. 505:117–38
  41. Carretta E, Bragaglia A, Gratton RG et al. 2010.b Astron. Astrophys. 516:A55
  42. Carretta E, Gratton RG, Bragaglia A, D'Orazi V, Lucatello S 2013. Astron. Astrophys. 550:A34
  43. Cassisi S, Salaris M, Anderson J et al. 2009. Ap. J. 702:1530–35
  44. Cassisi S, Salaris M, Irwin AW 2003. Ap. J. 588:862–70
  45. Cassisi S, Salaris M, Pietrinferni A, Hyder D 2017. MNRAS 464:2341–48
  46. Cassisi S, Salaris M, Pietrinferni A, Vink JS, Monelli M 2014. Astron. Astrophys. 571:A81
  47. Cassisi S, Salaris M, Pietrinferni A et al. 2008. Ap. J. Lett. 672:L115
  48. Chantereau W, Charbonnel C, Meynet G 2016. Astron. Astrophys. 592:A111
  49. Chantereau W, Usher C, Bastian N 2018. MNRAS 478(2):2368–87
  50. Charbonnel C 2016. Stellar Clusters: Benchmarks of Stellar Physics and Galactic Evolution - EES2015, EAS Publ. Ser.Vol 80–81 E Moraux, Y Lebreton, C Charbonnel 177–226 Paris: EAS Publ. Ser.
  51. Charbonnel C, Chantereau W, Krause M, Primas F, Wang Y 2014. Astron. Astrophys. 569:L6
  52. Cohen JG 2004. Astron. J. 127:1545–54
  53. Colucci JE, Bernstein RA, Cameron SA, McWilliam A 2012. Ap. J. 746:29
  54. Colucci JE, Bernstein RA, Cohen JG 2014. Ap. J. 797:116
  55. Conroy C 2012. Ap. J. 758:21
  56. Conroy C, Graves GJ, van Dokkum PG 2014. Ap. J. 780:33
  57. Conroy C, Spergel DN 2011. Ap. J. 726:36
  58. Cordero MJ, Hénault-Brunet V, Pilachowski CA et al. 2017. MNRAS 465:3515–35
  59. Cottrell PL, Da Costa GS 1981. Ap. J. Lett. 245:L79–82
  60. Dalessandro E, Lapenna E, Mucciarelli A et al. 2016. Ap. J. 829:77
  61. Dalessandro E, Massari D, Bellazzini M et al. 2014. Ap. J. Lett. 791:L4
  62. Dalessandro E, Salaris M, Ferraro FR, Mucciarelli A, Cassisi S 2013. MNRAS 430:459–71
  63. Dalessandro E, Salaris M, Ferraro FR et al. 2011. MNRAS 410:694–704
  64. D'Antona F, Bellazzini M, Caloi V et al. 2005. Ap. J. 631:868–78
  65. D'Antona F, Caloi V, Montalbán J, Ventura P, Gratton R 2002. Astron. Astrophys. 395:69–75
  66. D'Antona F, Caloi V, Ventura P 2010. MNRAS 405:2295–301
  67. D'Antona F, D'Ercole A, Marino AF et al. 2011. Ap. J. 736:5
  68. D'Antona F, Di Criscienzo M, Decressin T et al. 2015. MNRAS 453:2637–43
  69. D'Antona F, Vesperini E, D'Ercole A et al. 2016. MNRAS 458:2122–39
  70. D'Ercole A, D'Antona F, Ventura P, Vesperini E, McMillan SLW 2010. MNRAS 407:854–69
  71. D'Ercole A, D'Antona F, Vesperini E 2011. MNRAS 415:1304–9
  72. D'Ercole A, D'Antona F, Vesperini E 2016. MNRAS 461:4088–98
  73. D'Ercole A, Vesperini E, D'Antona F, McMillan SLW, Recchi S 2008. MNRAS 391:825–43
  74. D'Orazi V, Gratton R, Lucatello S et al. 2010. Ap. J. Lett. 719:L213–17
  75. D'Orazi V, Gratton RG, Angelou GC et al. 2015. MNRAS 449:4038–47
  76. Davies B, Figer DF, Law CJ et al. 2008. Ap. J. 676:1016–28
  77. de Mink SE, Pols OR, Langer N, Izzard RG 2009. Astron. Astrophys. 507:L1–4
  78. Decressin T, Charbonnel C, Meynet G 2007.a Astron. Astrophys. 475:859–73
  79. Decressin T, Charbonnel C, Siess L et al. 2009. Astron. Astrophys. 505:727–33
  80. Decressin T, Meynet G, Charbonnel C, Prantzos N, Ekström S 2007.b Astron. Astrophys. 464:1029–44
  81. Denisenkov PA, Denisenkova SN 1989. Astron. Tsirkulyar 1538:11
  82. Denisenkov PA, Denisenkova SN 1990. Sov. Astron. Lett. 16:275
  83. Denissenkov PA, Hartwick FDA 2014. MNRAS 437:L21–25
  84. Denissenkov PA, Herwig F 2003. Ap. J. Lett. 590:L99–102
  85. Di Criscienzo M, Tailo M, Milone AP et al. 2015. MNRAS 446:1469–77
  86. Dickens RJ, Croke BFW, Cannon RD, Bell RA 1991. Nature 351:212–14
  87. Doherty CL, Gil-Pons P, Lau HHB et al. 2014. MNRAS 441:582–98
  88. Dupree AK, Avrett EH 2013. Ap. J. Lett. 773:L28
  89. Dupree AK, Dotter A, Johnson CI et al. 2017. Ap. J. Lett. 846:L1
  90. Elmegreen BG 2017. Ap. J. 836:80
  91. Fenner Y, Campbell S, Karakas AI, Lattanzio JC, Gibson BK 2004. MNRAS 353:789–95
  92. Ferraro FR, Dalessandro E, Mucciarelli A et al. 2009. Nature 462:483–86
  93. Ferraro FR, Massari D, Dalessandro E et al. 2016. Ap. J. 828:75
  94. Georgy C, Granada A, Ekström S et al. 2014. Astron. Astrophys. 566:A21
  95. Gieles M, Charbonnel C, Krause MGH et al. 2018. MNRAS 478(2):2461–79
  96. Goudfrooij P, Girardi L, Kozhurina-Platais V et al. 2014. Ap. J. 797:35
  97. Gratton R, Sneden C, Carretta E 2004. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 42:385–440
  98. Gratton RG, Carretta E, Bragaglia A 2012.a Astron. Astrophys. Rev. 20:50
  99. Gratton RG, Carretta E, Bragaglia A, Lucatello S, D'Orazi V 2010. Astron. Astrophys. 517:A81
  100. Gratton RG, Lucatello S, Carretta E et al. 2012.b Astron. Astrophys. 539:A19
  101. Gratton RG, Lucatello S, Sollima A et al. 2014. Astron. Astrophys. 563:A13
  102. Grundahl F, Catelan M, Landsman WB, Stetson PB, Andersen MI 1999. Ap. J. 524:242–61
  103. Harris WE 1996. Astron. J. 112:1487
  104. Harris WE 2009. Ap. J. 699:254–80
  105. Harris WE, Harris GLH 2002. Astron. J. 123:3108–23
  106. Harris WE, Harris GLH, Alessi M 2013. Ap. J. 772:82
  107. Hartwick FDA, McClure RD 1972. Ap. J. Lett. 176:L57
  108. Hénault-Brunet V, Gieles M, Agertz O, Read JI 2015. MNRAS 450:1164–98
  109. Hernandez S, Larsen SS, Trager S, Groot P, Kaper L 2017. Astron. Astrophys. 306:119
  110. Hollyhead K, Bastian N, Adamo A et al. 2015. MNRAS 449:1106–17
  111. Hollyhead K, Kacharov N, Lardo C et al. 2017. MNRAS 465:L39–43
  112. Hopkins PF 2014. Ap. J. 797:59
  113. Ivans II, Sneden C, Kraft RP et al. 1999. Astron. J. 118:1273–300
  114. Johnson CI, Pilachowski CA 2010. Ap. J. 722:1373–410
  115. Johnson JA, Ivans II, Stetson PB 2006. Ap. J. 640:801–22
  116. Joo SJ, Lee YW 2013. Ap. J. 762:36
  117. Karakas A, Lattanzio JC 2007. Publ. Astron. Soc. Aust. 24:103–17
  118. Karakas AI, Lattanzio JC 2014. Publ. Astron. Soc. Aust. 31:e030
  119. Khalaj P, Baumgardt H 2016. MNRAS 457:479–86
  120. King IR, Bedin LR, Cassisi S et al. 2012. Astron. J. 144:5
  121. Koch A, Côté P, McWilliam A 2009. Astron. Astrophys. 506:729–43
  122. Krause M, Charbonnel C, Decressin T, Meynet G, Prantzos N 2013. Astron. Astrophys. 552:A121
  123. Krause M, Charbonnel C, Decressin T et al. 2012. Astron. Astrophys. 546:L5
  124. Krause MGH, Charbonnel C, Bastian N, Diehl R 2016. Astron. Astrophys. 587:A53
  125. Kruijssen JMD 2014. Class. Quantum Gravity 31:244006
  126. Kruijssen JMD 2015. MNRAS 454:1658–86
  127. Kruijssen JMD, Mieske S 2009. Astron. Astrophys. 500:785–99
  128. Kučinskas A, Dobrovolskas V, Bonifacio P 2014. Astron. Astrophys. 568:L4
  129. Langer GE, Hoffman R, Sneden C 1993. Publ. Astron. Soc. Pac. 105:301–7
  130. Lapenna E, Lardo C, Mucciarelli A et al. 2016. Ap. J. Lett. 826:L1
  131. Lapenna E, Mucciarelli A, Ferraro FR et al. 2015. Ap. J. 813:97
  132. Lardo C, Bellazzini M, Pancino E et al. 2011. Astron. Astrophys. 525:A114
  133. Lardo C, Cabrera-Ziri I, Davies B, Bastian N 2017.a MNRAS 468:2482–88
  134. Lardo C, Mucciarelli A, Bastian N 2016. MNRAS 457:51–63
  135. Lardo C, Salaris M, Bastian N et al. 2018. Astron. Astrophys. Accepted. arXiv:1805.09599
  136. Lardo C, Salaris M, Savino A et al. 2017.b MNRAS 466:33507–12
  137. Larsen SS 2004. Astron. Astrophys. 416:537–53
  138. Larsen SS, Baumgardt H, Bastian N et al. 2015. Ap. J. 804:71
  139. Larsen SS, Brodie JP, Forbes DA, Strader J 2014.a Astron. Astrophys. 565:A98
  140. Larsen SS, Brodie JP, Grundahl F, Strader J 2014.b Ap. J. 797:15
  141. Larsen SS, de Mink SE, Eldridge JJ et al. 2011. Astron. Astrophys. 532:A147
  142. Larsen SS, Strader J, Brodie JP 2012. Astron. Astrophys. 544:L14
  143. Lee JW 2016. Ap. J. Suppl. 226:16
  144. Lee JW 2017. Ap. J. 844:77
  145. Lee YW, Joo SJ, Chung C 2015. MNRAS 453:3906–11
  146. Letarte B, Hill V, Jablonka P et al. 2006. Astron. Astrophys. 453:547–54
  147. Li C, de Grijs R, Bastian N et al. 2016. MNRAS 461:3212–21
  148. Lim D, Hong S, Lee YW 2017. Ap. J. 844:14
  149. Lim D, Lee YW, Pasquato M, Han SI, Roh DG 2016. Ap. J. 832:99
  150. Lind K, Charbonnel C, Decressin T et al. 2011. Astron. Astrophys. 527:A148
  151. Lind K, Primas F, Charbonnel C, Grundahl F, Asplund M 2009. Astron. Astrophys. 503:545–57
  152. Lochhaas C, Thompson TA 2017. MNRAS 470:977–91
  153. Longmore SN 2015. MNRAS 448:L62–66
  154. Longmore SN, Kruijssen JMD, Bastian N et al. 2014. Protostars and Planets VI H Beuther, FS Klessen, CP Dullemond, T Henning 291–314 Tucson: Univ. Ariz. Press
  155. Loup C, Forveille T, Omont A, Paul JF 1993. Astron. Astrophys. Suppl. 99:291–377
  156. Lovisi L, Mucciarelli A, Lanzoni B et al. 2012. Ap. J. 754:91
  157. Lucatello S, Sollima A, Gratton R et al. 2015. Astron. Astrophys. 584:A52
  158. Mackey AD, Broby Nielsen P 2007. MNRAS 379:151–58
  159. Mackey AD, Broby Nielsen P, Ferguson AMN, Richardson JC 2008. Ap. J. Lett. 681:L17
  160. MacLean BT, De Silva GM, Lattanzio J 2015. MNRAS 446:3556–61
  161. Maeder A, Meynet G 2006. Astron. Astrophys. 448:L37–41
  162. Marcolini A, Gibson BK, Karakas AI, Sánchez-Blázquez P 2009. MNRAS 395:719–35
  163. Marino AF, Milone AP, Karakas AI et al. 2015. MNRAS 450:815–45
  164. Marino AF, Milone AP, Piotto G et al. 2011.a Ap. J. 731:64
  165. Marino AF, Milone AP, Sneden C et al. 2012. Astron. Astrophys. 541:A15
  166. Marino AF, Sneden C, Kraft RP et al. 2011.b Astron. Astrophys. 532:A8
  167. Marino AF, Villanova S, Piotto G et al. 2008. Astron. Astrophys. 490:625–40
  168. Martell SL, Smolinski JP, Beers TC, Grebel EK 2011. Astron. Astrophys. 534:A136
  169. Martocchia S, Bastian N, Usher C et al. 2017. MNRAS 468:3150–58
  170. Martocchia S, Cabrera-Ziri I, Lardo C et al. 2018.a MNRAS 473:2688–700
  171. Martocchia S, Niederhofer F, Dalessandro E et al. 2018.b MNRAS 477:4696–705
  172. Massari D, Lapenna E, Bragaglia A et al. 2016. MNRAS 458:4162–71
  173. Massari D, Mucciarelli A, Ferraro FR et al. 2014. Ap. J. 795:22
  174. Mastrobuono-Battisti A, Perets HB 2013. Ap. J. 779:85
  175. Mayya YD, Rosa-González D, Santiago-Cortés M et al. 2013. MNRAS 436:2763–73
  176. McDonald I, Zijlstra AA 2015. MNRAS 446:2226–42
  177. McSwain MV, Gies DR 2005. Ap. J. Suppl. 161:118–46
  178. Mészáros S, Martell SL, Shetrone M et al. 2015. Astron. J. 149:153
  179. Miholics M, Webb JJ, Sills A 2015. MNRAS 454:2166–72
  180. Milone AP 2015. MNRAS 446:1672–84
  181. Milone AP, Bedin LR, Piotto G, Anderson J 2009. Astron. Astrophys. 497:755–71
  182. Milone AP, Bedin LR, Piotto G et al. 2015.a MNRAS 450:3750–64
  183. Milone AP, Marino AF, D'Antona F et al. 2016. MNRAS 458:4368–82
  184. Milone AP, Marino AF, D'Antona F et al. 2017.a MNRAS 465:4363–74
  185. Milone AP, Marino AF, Piotto G et al. 2015.b Ap. J. 808:51
  186. Milone AP, Piotto G, Renzini A et al. 2017.b MNRAS 464:3636–56
  187. Moehler S, Dreizler S, LeBlanc F et al. 2014. Astron. Astrophys. 565:A100
  188. Monelli M, Milone AP, Stetson PB et al. 2013. MNRAS 431:2126–49
  189. Mucciarelli A, Bellazzini M, Ibata R et al. 2012. MNRAS 426:2889–900
  190. Mucciarelli A, Carretta E, Origlia L, Ferraro FR 2008. Astron. J. 136:375–88
  191. Mucciarelli A, Dalessandro E, Ferraro FR, Origlia L, Lanzoni B 2014.a Ap. J. Lett. 793:L6
  192. Mucciarelli A, Lapenna E, Massari D et al. 2015. Ap. J. 809:128
  193. Mucciarelli A, Lovisi L, Lanzoni B, Ferraro FR 2014.b Ap. J. 786:14
  194. Mucciarelli A, Origlia L, Ferraro FR, Pancino E 2009. Ap. J. Lett. 695:L134–39
  195. Mucciarelli A, Salaris M, Lovisi L et al. 2011. MNRAS 412:81–94
  196. Nardiello D, Piotto G, Milone AP et al. 2015. MNRAS 451:312–22
  197. Niederhofer F, Bastian N, Kozhurina-Platais V et al. 2017.a MNRAS 464:94–103
  198. Niederhofer F, Bastian N, Kozhurina-Platais V et al. 2017.b MNRAS 465:4159–65
  199. Niederhofer F, Georgy C, Bastian N, Ekström S 2015. MNRAS 453:2070–74
  200. Norris J 1987. Ap. J. Lett. 313:L65–68
  201. Norris J, Cottrell PL, Freeman KC, Da Costa GS 1981. Ap. J. 244:205–20
  202. Norris JE, Yong D, Venn KA et al. 2017. Ap. J. Suppl. 230:28
  203. O'Connell RW 1999. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 37:603–48
  204. Origlia L, Rich RM, Ferraro FR et al. 2011. Ap. J. Lett. 726:L20
  205. Osborn W 1971. Observatory 91:223–24
  206. Pancino E 2018. Astron. Astrophys Accepted. arXiv:1802.06654
  207. Pancino E, Romano D, Tang B et al. 2017. Astron. Astrophys. 601:A112
  208. Pasquini L, Bonifacio P, Molaro P et al. 2005. Astron. Astrophys. 441:549–53
  209. Pasquini L, Mauas P, Käufl HU, Cacciari C 2011. Astron. Astrophys. 531:A35
  210. Peacock MB, Zepf SE, Finzell T 2013. Ap. J. 769:126
  211. Peacock MB, Zepf SE, Kundu A, Chael J 2017. MNRAS 464:713–20
  212. Pfeffer J, Kruijssen JMD, Crain RA, Bastian N 2018. MNRAS 475:4309–46
  213. Piatti AE, Keller SC, Mackey AD, Da Costa GS 2014. MNRAS 444:1425–41
  214. Pietrinferni A, Cassisi S, Salaris M, Percival S, Ferguson JW 2009. Ap. J. 697:275–82
  215. Piotto G, Bedin LR, Anderson J et al. 2007. Ap. J. Lett. 661:L53–56
  216. Piotto G, Milone AP, Anderson J et al. 2012. Ap. J. 760:39
  217. Piotto G, Milone AP, Bedin LR et al. 2015. Astron. J. 149:91
  218. Piotto G, Villanova S, Bedin LR et al. 2005. Ap. J. 621:777–84
  219. Portegies Zwart SF, McMillan SLW, Gieles M 2010. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 48:431–93
  220. Prantzos N, Charbonnel C 2006. Astron. Astrophys. 458:135–49
  221. Prantzos N, Charbonnel C, Iliadis C 2007. Astron. Astrophys. 470:179–90
  222. Prantzos N, Charbonnel C, Iliadis C 2017. Astron. Astrophys. 608:28–40
  223. Recio-Blanco A, Aparicio A, Piotto G, de Angeli F, Djorgovski SG 2006. Astron. Astrophys. 452:875–84
  224. Reines AE, Johnson KE, Goss WM 2008. Astron. J. 135:2222–39
  225. Renzini A 2008. MNRAS 391:354–62
  226. Renzini A 2013. Mem. Soc. Astron. Ital. 84:162
  227. Renzini A 2017. MNRAS 469:L63–67
  228. Renzini A, D'Antona F, Cassisi S et al. 2015. MNRAS 454:4197–207
  229. Richer HB, Heyl J, Anderson J et al. 2013. Ap. J. Lett. 771:L15
  230. Roediger JC, Courteau S, Graves G, Schiavon RP 2014. Ap. J. Suppl. 210:10
  231. Rood RT 1973. Ap. J. 184:815–38
  232. Sakari CM, Venn KA, Mackey D et al. 2015. MNRAS 448:1314–34
  233. Salaris M, Cassisi S 2014. Astron. Astrophys. 566:A109
  234. Salaris M, Weiss A, Ferguson JW, Fusilier DJ 2006. Ap. J. 645:1131–37
  235. Salinas R, Strader J 2015. Ap. J. 809:169
  236. Sánchez-Blázquez P, Marcolini A, Gibson BK et al. 2012. MNRAS 419:1376–89
  237. Sarajedini A, Bedin LR, Chaboyer B et al. 2007. Astron. J. 133:1658–72
  238. Savino A, Salaris M, Tolstoy E 2015. Astron. Astrophys. 583:A126
  239. Sbordone L, Bonifacio P, Buonanno R et al. 2007. Astron. Astrophys. 465:815–24
  240. Sbordone L, Salaris M, Weiss A, Cassisi S 2011. Astron. Astrophys. 534:A9
  241. Schaerer D, Charbonnel C 2011. MNRAS 413:2297–304
  242. Schaeuble M, Preston G, Sneden C et al. 2015. Astron. J. 149:204
  243. Schiavon RP 2007. Ap. J. Suppl. 171:146–205
  244. Schiavon RP, Caldwell N, Conroy C et al. 2013. Ap. J. Lett. 776:L7
  245. Schiavon RP, Johnson JA, Frinchaboy PM et al. 2017.a MNRAS 466:1010–18
  246. Schiavon RP, Zamora O, Carrera R et al. 2017.b MNRAS 465:501–24
  247. Shen ZX, Bonifacio P, Pasquini L, Zaggia S 2010. Astron. Astrophys. 524:L2
  248. Sills A, Glebbeek E 2010. MNRAS 407:277–84
  249. Simioni M, Milone AP, Bedin LR et al. 2016. MNRAS 463:449–58
  250. Slemer A, Marigo P, Piatti D et al. 2017. MNRAS 465:4817–37
  251. Smith GH 2015. Publ. Astron. Soc. Pac. 127:1204–17
  252. Sneden C 2000. Proc. 35th Liège Int. Astrophys. Colloq., Liège, Belgium, Jul. 5–8, 1999 A Noels, P Magain, D Caro, E Jehin, G Parmentier, AA Thoul 159–75 Liege: Univ. Liege
  253. Sneden C, Kraft RP, Prosser CF, Langer GE 1992. Astron. J. 104:2121–40
  254. Sohn ST, O'Connell RW, Kundu A et al. 2006. Astron. J. 131:866–88
  255. Soto M, Bellini A, Anderson J et al. 2017. Astron. J. 153:19–29
  256. Strader J, Seth AC, Forbes DA et al. 2013. Ap. J. Lett. 775:L6
  257. Strader J, Smith GH 2008. Astron. J. 136:1828–36
  258. Szécsi D, Mackey J, Langer N 2018. Astron. Astrophys. 612:A55
  259. Tailo M, Di Criscienzo M, D'Antona F, Caloi V, Ventura P 2016. MNRAS 457:4525–35
  260. Takeda Y, Kaneko H, Matsumoto N et al. 2009. Publ. Astron. Soc. Jpn. 61:563–76
  261. Tautvaišienė G, Wallerstein G, Geisler D, Gonzalez G, Charbonnel C 2004. Astron. J. 127:373–79
  262. Tenorio-Tagle G, Silich S, Rodríguez-González A, Muñoz-Tuñón C 2005. Ap. J. 628:L13–16
  263. Trenti M, Padoan P, Jimenez R 2015. Ap. J. Lett. 808:L35
  264. Usher C, Pfeffer J, Bastian N et al. 2018. MNRAS Submitted
  265. van Dokkum P, Conroy C, Villaume A, Brodie J, Romanowsky A 2017. Ap. J. 841:68–91
  266. Vanderbeke J, De Propris R, De Rijcke S et al. 2015. MNRAS 451:275–81
  267. Vanzella E, Calura F, Meneghetti M et al. 2017. MNRAS 467:4304–21
  268. Ventura P, D'Antona F 2005.a Astron. Astrophys. 431:279–88
  269. Ventura P, D'Antona F 2005.b Astron. Astrophys. 439:1075–91
  270. Ventura P, D'Antona F 2006. Astron. Astrophys. 457:995–1001
  271. Ventura P, D'Antona F 2009. Astron. Astrophys. 499:835–46
  272. Ventura P, D'Antona F, Di Criscienzo M et al. 2012. Ap. J. Lett. 761:L30
  273. Ventura P, D'Antona F, Mazzitelli I 2002. Astron. Astrophys. 393:215–23
  274. Ventura P, Di Criscienzo M, Carini R, D'Antona F 2013. MNRAS 431:3642–53
  275. Ventura P, García-Hernández DA, Dell'Agli F et al. 2016. Ap. J. Lett. 831:L17
  276. Vesperini E, McMillan SLW, D'Antona F, D'Ercole A 2010. Ap. J. Lett. 718:L112–16
  277. Vesperini E, McMillan SLW, D'Antona F, D'Ercole A 2013. MNRAS 429:1913–21
  278. Villanova S, Geisler D, Carraro G, Moni Bidin C, Muñoz C 2013. Ap. J. 778:186
  279. Villanova S, Piotto G, Gratton RG 2009. Astron. Astrophys. 499:755–63
  280. Vink JS, Muijres LE, Anthonisse B et al. 2011. Astron. Astrophys. 531:A132
  281. Walcher CJ, Coelho PRT, Gallazzi A et al. 2015. Astron. Astrophys. 582:A46
  282. Walker AR, Kunder AM, Andreuzzi G et al. 2011. MNRAS 415:643–54
  283. Wang Y, Primas F, Charbonnel C et al. 2017. Astron. Astrophys. 607:135
  284. Webb JJ, Leigh NWC 2015. MNRAS 453:3278–87
  285. Whitmore BC, Zhang Q 2002. Astron. J. 124:1418–34
  286. Wijnen TPG, Pols OR, Pelupessy FI, Portegies Zwart S 2016. Astron. Astrophys. 594:A30
  287. Willman B, Strader J 2012. Astron. J. 144:76
  288. Wünsch R, Palouš J, Tenorio-Tagle G, Ehlerová S 2017. Ap. J. 835:60
  289. Yong D, Grundahl F, Johnson JA, Asplund M 2008. Ap. J. 684:1159–69
  290. Yong D, Grundahl F, Lambert DL, Nissen PE, Shetrone MD 2003. Astron. Astrophys. 402:985–1001
  291. Yong D, Grundahl F, Nissen PE, Jensen HR, Lambert DL 2005. Astron. Astrophys. 438:875–88
  292. Yong D, Grundahl F, Norris JE 2015. MNRAS 446:3319–29
  293. Yong D, Roederer IU, Grundahl F et al. 2014. MNRAS 441:3396–416
/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-astro-081817-051839
Loading
Multiple Stellar Populations in Globular Clusters
Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics 56, 83 (2018); https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-astro-081817-051839
/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-astro-081817-051839
/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-astro-081817-051839
Loading

Data & Media loading...

  • Article Type: Review Article

Most Cited Most Cited RSS feed

This is a required field
Please enter a valid email address
Approval was a Success
Invalid data
An Error Occurred
Approval was partially successful, following selected items could not be processed due to error