Advances in the Use of Microfluidics to Study Crystallization Fundamentals

Literature Cited

1. 1.

   Veesler S, Puel F. 2015. Crystallization of pharmaceutical crystals. Handbook of Crystal Growth T Nishinaga 915–49 Boston: Elsevier, 2nd ed..
   [Google Scholar]
2. 2.

   Candoni N, Grossier R, Hammadi Z, Morin R, Veesler S 2012. Practical physics behind growing crystals of biological macromolecules. Protein Peptide Lett 19:714–24
   [Google Scholar]
3. 3.

   Mangin D, Puel F, Veesler S 2009. Polymorphism in processes of crystallization in solution: a practical review. Org. Process Res. Dev. 13:1241–53
   [Google Scholar]
4. 4.

   Kashchiev D. 2000. Nucleation: Basic Theory with Applications Oxford, UK: Butterworth-Heinemann529
5. 5.

   Galkin O, Vekilov PG. 2000. Are nucleation kinetics of protein crystals similar to those of liquid droplets?. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 122:156–63
   [Google Scholar]
6. 6.

   Hammadi Z, Grossier R, Zhang S, Ikni A, Candoni N et al. 2015. Localizing and inducing primary nucleation. Faraday Discuss 179:489–501
   [Google Scholar]
7. 7.

   Jiang S, ter Horst JH 2011. Crystal nucleation rates from probability distributions of induction times. Cryst. Growth Des. 11:256–61
   [Google Scholar]
8. 8.

   Svärd M, Nordström FL, Jasnobulka T, Rasmuson ÅC 2009. Thermodynamics and nucleation kinetics of m-aminobenzoic acid polymorphs. Cryst. Growth Des. 10:195–204
   [Google Scholar]
9. 9.

   Li L, Mustafi D, Fu Q, Tereshko V, Chen DL et al. 2006. Nanoliter microfluidic hybrid method for simultaneous screening and optimization validated with crystallization of membrane proteins. PNAS 103:19243–48
   [Google Scholar]
10. 10.

    Shim J-U, Cristobal G, Link DR, Thorsen T, Fraden S 2007. Using microfluidics to decouple nucleation and growth of protein. Cryst. Growth Des. 7:2192–94
    [Google Scholar]
11. 11.

    Squires TM, Quake SR. 2005. Microfluidics: fluid physics at the nanoliter scale. Rev. Mod. Phys. 77:977
    [Google Scholar]
12. 12.

    Dombrowski RD, Litster JD, Wagner NJ, He Y 2007. Crystallization of alpha-lactose monohydrate in a drop-based microfluidic crystallizer. Chem. Eng. Sci. 62:4802–10
    [Google Scholar]
13. 13.

    Hansen CL, Skordalakes E, Berger JM, Quake SR 2002. A robust and scalable microfluidic metering method that allows protein crystal growth by free interface diffusion. PNAS 99:16531–36
    [Google Scholar]
14. 14.

    Perry SL, Guha S, Pawate AS, Bhaskarla A, Agarwal V et al. 2013. A microfluidic approach for protein structure determination at room temperature via on-chip anomalous diffraction. Lab Chip 13:3183–87
    [Google Scholar]
15. 15.

    Dhouib K, Malek CK, Pfleging W, Gauthier-Manuel B, Duffait R et al. 2009. Microfluidic chips for the crystallization of biomacromolecules by counter-diffusion and on-chip crystal X-ray analysis. Lab Chip 9:1412–21
    [Google Scholar]
16. 16.

    Otálora F, Gavira JA, Ng JD, García-Ruiz JM 2009. Counterdiffusion methods applied to protein crystallization. Prog. Biophys. Mol. Biol. 101:26–37
    [Google Scholar]
17. 17.

    Li L, Ismagilov RF. 2010. Protein crystallization using microfluidic technologies based on valves, droplets, and SlipChip. Annu. Rev. Biophys. 39:139–58
    [Google Scholar]
18. 18.

    Zheng B, Gerdts CJ, Ismagilov RF 2005. Using nanoliter plugs in microfluidics to facilitate and understand protein crystallization. Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol. 15:548–55
    [Google Scholar]
19. 19.

    Gerdts CJ, Elliott M, Lovell S, Mixon MB, Napuli AJ et al. 2008. The plug-based nanovolume Microcapillary Protein Crystallization System (MPCS). Acta Crystallogr. D 64:1116–22
    [Google Scholar]
20. 20.

    Ildefonso M, Candoni N, Veesler S 2012. A cheap, easy microfluidic crystallization device ensuring universal solvent compatibility. Org. Process Res. Dev. 16:556–60
    [Google Scholar]
21. 21.

    Ildefonso M, Revalor E, Punniam P, Salmon JB, Candoni N, Veesler S 2012. Nucleation and polymorphism explored via an easy-to-use microfluidic tool. J. Cryst. Growth 342:9–12
    [Google Scholar]
22. 22.

    Zhang S, Ferté N, Candoni N, Veesler S 2015. Versatile microfluidic approach to crystallization. Org. Process Res. Dev. 19:1837–41
    [Google Scholar]
23. 23.

    Candoni N, Hammadi Z, Grossier R, Ildefonso M, Morin R, Veesler S 2015. Addressing the stochasticity of nucleation: practical approaches. Advances in Organic Crystal Chemistry R Tamura, M Miyata 95–113 Tokyo: Springer
    [Google Scholar]
24. 24.

    Whitesides GM. 2006. The origins and the future of microfluidics. Nature 442:368–73
    [Google Scholar]
25. 25.

    Beebe DJ, Moore JS, Bauer JM, Yu Q, Liu RH et al. 2000. Functional hydrogel structures for autonomous flow control inside microfluidic channels. Nature 404:588–90
    [Google Scholar]
26. 26.

    Unger MA, Chou H-P, Thorsen T, Scherer A, Quake SR 2000. Monolithic microfabricated valves and pumps by multilayer soft lithography. Science 288:113–16
    [Google Scholar]
27. 27.

    McDonald JC, Whitesides GM. 2002. Poly(dimethylsiloxane) as a material for fabricating microfluidic devices. Acc. Chem. Res. 35:491–99
    [Google Scholar]
28. 28.

    Zhang S, Gerard CJJ, Ikni A, Ferry G, Vuillard LM et al. 2017. Microfluidic platform for optimization of crystallization conditions. J. Cryst. Growth 472:18–28
    [Google Scholar]
29. 29.

    Gerard CJJ, Ferry G, Vuillard LM, Boutin JA, Ferte N et al. 2018. A chemical library to screen protein and protein–ligand crystallization using a versatile microfluidic platform. Cryst. Growth Des. 18:5130–37
    [Google Scholar]
30. 30.

    Ildefonso M, Candoni N, Veesler S 2013. Heterogeneous nucleation in droplet-based nucleation measurements. Cryst. Growth Des. 13:2107–10
    [Google Scholar]
31. 31.

    Gerard CJJ, Ferry G, Vuillard LM, Boutin JA, Chavas LMG et al. 2017. Crystallization via tubing microfluidics permits both in situ and ex situ X-ray diffraction. Acta Crystallogr. Sect. F 73:574–78
    [Google Scholar]
32. 32.

    Ildefonso M, Candoni N, Veesler S 2011. Using microfluidics for fast, accurate measurement of lysozyme nucleation kinetics. Cryst. Growth Des. 11:1527–30
    [Google Scholar]
33. 33.

    Peybernès G, Grossier R, Villard F, Letellier P, Lagaize M et al. 2018. Microfluidics setup rapidly measures solubility directly from powder. Org. Process Res. Dev. 22:1856–60
    [Google Scholar]
34. 34.

    Garstecki P, Fuerstman MJ, Stone HA, Whitesides GM 2006. Formation of droplets and bubbles in a microfluidic T-junction-scaling and mechanism of break-up. Lab Chip 6:437–46
    [Google Scholar]
35. 35.

    Xu JH, Li SW, Tan J, Luo GS 2008. Correlations of droplet formation in T-junction microfluidic devices: from squeezing to dripping. Microfluid. Nanofluidics 5:711–17
    [Google Scholar]
36. 36.

    Christopher GF, Noharuddin NN, Taylor JA, Anna SL 2008. Experimental observations of the squeezing-to-dripping transition in T-shaped microfluidic junctions. Phys. Rev. E 78:036317
    [Google Scholar]
37. 37.

    Liu H, Zhang Y. 2009. Droplet formation in a T-shaped microfluidic junction. J. Appl. Phys. 106:034906
    [Google Scholar]
38. 38.

    Gupta A, Kumar R. 2010. Flow regime transition at high capillary numbers in a microfluidic T-junction: viscosity contrast and geometry effect. Phys. Fluids 22:122001
    [Google Scholar]
39. 39.

    Glawdel T, Elbuken C, Ren CL 2012. Droplet formation in microfluidic T-junction generators operating in the transitional regime. I. Experimental observations. Phys. Rev. E 85:016322
    [Google Scholar]
40. 40.

    Glawdel T, Elbuken C, Ren CL 2012. Droplet formation in microfluidic T-junction generators operating in the transitional regime. II. Modeling. Phys. Rev. E 85:016323
    [Google Scholar]
41. 41.

    Wehking J, Gabany M, Chew L, Kumar R 2013. Effects of viscosity, interfacial tension, and flow geometry on droplet formation in a microfluidic T-junction. Microfluid. Nanofluidics 16:441–53
    [Google Scholar]
42. 42.

    Thorsen T, Roberts RW, Arnold FH, Quake SR 2001. Dynamic pattern formation in a vesicle-generating microfluidic device. Phys. Rev. Lett. 86:4163–66
    [Google Scholar]
43. 43.

    van Steijn V, Kleijn CR, Kreutzer MT 2010. Predictive model for the size of bubbles and droplets created in microfluidic T-junctions. Lab Chip 10:2513–18
    [Google Scholar]
44. 44.

    Garstecki P, Stone HA, Whitesides GM 2005. Mechanism for flow-rate controlled breakup in confined geometries: a route to monodisperse emulsions. Phys. Rev. Lett. 94:164501
    [Google Scholar]
45. 45.

    Tice JD, Song H, Lyon AD, Ismagilov RF 2003. Formation of droplets and mixing in multiphase microfluidics at low values of the Reynolds and the capillary numbers. Langmuir 19:9127–33
    [Google Scholar]
46. 46.

    Zhao C-X, Middelberg APJ. 2011. Two-phase microfluidic flows. Chem. Eng. Sci. 66:1394–411
    [Google Scholar]
47. 47.

    Chen N, Wu J, Jiang H, Dong L 2011. CFD simulation of droplet formation in a wide-type microfluidic T-junction. J. Dispers. Sci. Technol. 33:1635–41
    [Google Scholar]
48. 48.

    Zhang S, Guivier-Curien C, Veesler S, Candoni N 2015. Prediction of sizes and frequencies of nanoliter-sized droplets in cylindrical T-junction microfluidics. Chem. Eng. Sci. 138:128–39
    [Google Scholar]
49. 49.

    Song H, Bringer MR, Tice JD, Gerdts CJ, Ismagilov RF 2003. Experimental test of scaling of mixing by chaotic advection in droplets moving through microfluidic channels. Appl. Phys. Lett. 83:4664–66
    [Google Scholar]
50. 50.

    Trivedi V, Doshi A, Kurup GK, Ereifej E, Vandevord PJ, Basu AS 2010. A modular approach for the generation, storage, mixing, and detection of droplet libraries for high throughput screening. Lab Chip 10:2433–42
    [Google Scholar]
51. 51.

    Baroud CN, Gallaire F, Dangla R 2010. Dynamics of microfluidic droplets. Lab Chip 10:2032–45
    [Google Scholar]
52. 52.

    Chayen NE, Shaw Stewart PD, Maeder DL, Blow DM 1990. An automated system for micro-batch protein crystallization and screening. J. Appl. Crystallogr. 23:297–302
    [Google Scholar]
53. 53.

    Candoni N, Hammadi Z, Grossier R, Ildefonso M, Revalor E et al. 2012. Nanotechnologies dedicated to nucleation control. Int. J. Nanotechnol. 9:439–59
    [Google Scholar]
54. 54.

    Dunuwila DD, Berglund KA. 1997. ATR FTIR spectroscopy for in situ measurement of supersaturation. J. Cryst. Growth 179:185–93
    [Google Scholar]
55. 55.

    Lewiner F, Klein JP, Puel F, Févotte G 2001. On-line ATR FTIR measurement of supersaturation during solution crystallization processes. Calibration and applications on three solute/solvent systems. Chem. Eng. Sci. 56:2069–84
    [Google Scholar]
56. 56.

    Schwartz AM, Berglund KA. 1999. The use of Raman spectroscopy for in situ monitoring of lysozyme concentration during crystallization in a hanging drop. J. Cryst. Growth 203:599–603
    [Google Scholar]
57. 57.

    Laval P, Lisai N, Salmon JB, Joanicot M 2007. A microfluidic device based on droplet storage for screening solubility diagrams. Lab Chip 7:829–34
    [Google Scholar]
58. 58.

    Leng J, Salmon JB. 2009. Microfluidic crystallization. Lab Chip 9:24–34
    [Google Scholar]
59. 59.

    Bustamante P, Romero S, Peña A, Escalera B, Reillo A 1998. Enthalpy–entropy compensation for the solubility of drugs in solvent mixtures: paracetamol, acetanilide, and nalidixic acid in dioxane–water. J. Pharm. Sci. 87:1590–96
    [Google Scholar]
60. 60.

    Hojjati H, Rohani S. 2006. Measurement and prediction of solubility of paracetamol in water−isopropanol solution. Part 1. Measurement and data analysis. Org. Process Res. Dev. 10:1101–9
    [Google Scholar]
61. 61.

    Granberg RA, Rasmuson ÅC 1999. Solubility of paracetamol in pure solvents. J. Chem. Eng. Data 44:1391–95
    [Google Scholar]
62. 62.

    Nagai T, Prakongpan S. 1984. Solubility of acetaminophen in cosolvents. Chem. Pharm. Bull. 32:340–43
    [Google Scholar]
63. 63.

    Bustamante P, Romero S, Reillo A 1995. Thermodynamics of paracetamol in amphiprotic and amphiprotic-aprotic solvent mixtures. Pharm. Sci. 1:505–7
    [Google Scholar]
64. 64.

    Jouyban A, Chan H-K, Chew NYK, Khoubnasabjafari M, Acree WE Jr 2006. Solubility prediction of paracetamol in binary and ternary solvent mixtures using Jouyban–Acree model. Chem. Pharm. Bull. 54:428–31
    [Google Scholar]
65. 65.

    Jiménez JA, Martínez F. 2006. Thermodynamic study of the solubility of acetaminophen in propylene glycol + water cosolvent mixtures. J. Braz. Chem. Soc. 17:125–34
    [Google Scholar]
66. 66.

    Detoisien T, Forite M, Taulelle P, Teston J, Colson D et al. 2009. A rapid method for screening crystallization conditions and phases of an active pharmaceutical ingredient. Org. Process Res. Dev. 13:1338–42
    [Google Scholar]
67. 67.

    Kashchiev D, Verdoes D, Van Rosmalen GM 1991. Induction time and metastability limit in new phase formation. J. Cryst. Growth 110:373–80
    [Google Scholar]
68. 68.

    Revalor E, Hammadi Z, Astier JP, Grossier R, Garcia E et al. 2010. Usual and unusual crystallization from solution. J. Cryst. Growth 312:939–46
    [Google Scholar]
69. 69.

    Ostwald W. 1897. Studien uber die bildung und umwandlund fester korper. Z. Phys. Chem. 22:289–330
    [Google Scholar]
70. 70.

    Ataka M, Asai M. 1988. Systematic studies on the crystallization of lysozyme. J. Cryst. Growth 90:86–93
    [Google Scholar]
71. 71.

    Legrand L, Ries-Kautt M, Robert M-C 2002. Two polymorphs of lysozyme nitrate: temperature dependence of their solubility. Acta Crystallogr. D 58:1564–67
    [Google Scholar]
72. 72.

    Astier JP, Veesler S. 2008. Using temperature to crystallize proteins: a mini-review. Cryst. Growth Des. 8:4215–19
    [Google Scholar]
73. 73.

    Lee AY, Lee IS, Myerson AS 2006. Factors affecting the polymorphic outcome of glycine crystals constrained on patterned substrates. Chem. Eng. Technol. 29:281–85
    [Google Scholar]
74. 74.

    Laval P, Giroux C, Leng J, Salmon J-B 2008. Microfluidic screening of potassium nitrate polymorphism. J. Cryst. Growth 310:3121–24
    [Google Scholar]
75. 75.

    Vivares D, Veesler S, Astier JP, Bonneté F 2006. Polymorphism of urate oxidase in PEG solutions. Cryst. Growth Des. 6:287–92
    [Google Scholar]
76. 76.

    Tsekova D, Dimitrova S, Nanev CN 1999. Heterogeneous nucleation (and adhesion) of lysozyme crystals. J. Cryst. Growth 196:226–33
    [Google Scholar]
77. 77.

    Galkin O, Vekilov PG. 1999. Direct determination of the nucleation rates of protein crystals. J. Phys. Chem. B 103:10965–71
    [Google Scholar]
78. 78.

    Selimovic S, Jia Y, Fraden S 2009. Measuring the nucleation rate of lysozyme using microfluidics. Cryst. Growth Des. 9:1806–10
    [Google Scholar]
79. 79.

    Grossier R, Magnaldo A, Veesler S 2010. Ultra-fast crystallization due to confinement. J. Cryst. Growth 312:487–89
    [Google Scholar]
80. 80.

    Grossier R, Veesler S. 2009. Reaching one single and stable critical cluster through finite sized systems. Cryst. Growth Des. 9:1917–22
    [Google Scholar]
81. 81.

    Gibbs J. 1948. The Collected Works 1 Thermodynamics New Haven, CT: Yale Univ. Press
82. 82.

    Chayen NE. 1996. A novel technique for containerless protein crystallization. Protein Eng 9:927–29
    [Google Scholar]
83. 83.

    Song H, Chen DL, Ismagilov RF 2006. Reactions in droplets in microfluidic channels. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 45:7336–56
    [Google Scholar]
84. 84.

    Song H, Tice JD, Ismagilov RF 2003. A microfluidic system for controlling reaction networks in time. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 42:768–72
    [Google Scholar]
85. 85.

    Poe SL, Cummings MA, Haaf MP, McQuade DT 2006. Solving the clogging problem: precipitate-forming reactions in flow. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 45:1544–48
    [Google Scholar]
86. 86.

    Zheng B, Roach LS, Ismagilov RF 2003. Screening of protein crystallization conditions on a microfluidic chip using nanoliter-size droplets. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 125:11170–71
    [Google Scholar]
87. 87.

    Blundell TL, Jhoti H, Abell C 2002. High-throughput crystallography for lead discovery in drug design. Nat. Rev. Drug Discov. 1:45–54
    [Google Scholar]
88. 88.

    Mande SC, Sobhia ME. 2000. Structural characterization of protein–denaturant interactions: crystal structures of hen egg-white lysozyme in complex with DMSO and guanidinium chloride. Protein Eng. Des. Select. 13:133–41
    [Google Scholar]
89. 89.

    Maeki M, Yamaguchi H, Tokeshi M, Miyazaki M 2016. Microfluidic approaches for protein crystal structure analysis. Anal. Sci. 32:3–9
    [Google Scholar]
90. 90.

    Stojanoff V, Jakoncic J, Oren DA, Nagarajan V, Navarro Poulsen J-C et al. 2011. From screen to structure with a harvestable microfluidic device. Acta Crystallogr. F 67:971–75
    [Google Scholar]
91. 91.

    Guha S, Perry SL, Pawate AS, Kenis PJA 2012. Fabrication of X-ray compatible microfluidic platforms for protein crystallization. Sensors Actuators B 174:1–9
    [Google Scholar]
92. 92.

    Pinker F, Brun M, Morin P, Deman A-L, Chateaux J-F et al. 2013. ChipX: a novel microfluidic chip for counter-diffusion crystallization of biomolecules and in situ crystal analysis at room temperature. Cryst. Growth Des. 13:3333–40
    [Google Scholar]
93. 93.

    Khvostichenko DS, Schieferstein JM, Pawate AS, Laible PD, Kenis PJA 2014. X-ray transparent microfluidic chip for mesophase-based crystallization of membrane proteins and on-chip structure determination. Crystal Growth Des 14:4886–90
    [Google Scholar]
94. 94.

    Horstman EM, Goyal S, Pawate A, Lee G, Zhang GGZ et al. 2015. Crystallization optimization of pharmaceutical solid forms with X-ray compatible microfluidic platforms. Crystal Growth Des 15:1201–9
    [Google Scholar]
95. 95.

    Heymann M, Opathalage A, Wierman JL, Akella S, Szebenyi DME et al. 2015. Room-temperature serial crystallography using a kinetically optimized microfluidic device for protein crystallization and on-chip X-ray diffraction. Corrigendum. IUCrJ 2:601
    [Google Scholar]
96. 96.

    Maeki M, Pawate AS, Yamashita K, Kawamoto M, Tokeshi M et al. 2015. A method of cryoprotection for protein crystallography by using a microfluidic chip and its application for in situ X-ray diffraction measurements. Anal. Chem. 87:4194–200
    [Google Scholar]
97. 97.

    Sui S, Perry SL. 2017. Microfluidics: from crystallization to serial time-resolved crystallography. Struct. Dyn. 4:032202
    [Google Scholar]
98. 98.

    Yadav MK, Gerdts CJ, Sanishvili R, Smith WW, Roach LS et al. 2005. In situ data collection and structure refinement from microcapillary protein crystallization. J. Appl. Crystallogr. 38:900–5
    [Google Scholar]
99. 99.

    Maeki M, Yoshizuka S, Yamaguchi H, Kawamoto M, Yamashita K et al. 2012. X-ray diffraction of protein crystal grown in a nano-liter scale droplet in a microchannel and evaluation of its applicability. Anal. Sci. 28:65
    [Google Scholar]
100. 100.

     Gerdts CJ, Stahl GL, Napuli A, Staker B, Abendroth J et al. 2010. Nanovolume optimization of protein crystal growth using the microcapillary protein crystallization system. J. Appl. Crystallogr. 43:1078–83
     [Google Scholar]
101. 101.

     Foster CE, Bianchet MA, Talalay P, Zhao Q, Amzel LM 1999. Crystal structure of human quinone reductase type 2, a metalloflavoprotein. Biochemistry 38:9881–86
     [Google Scholar]
102. 102.

     Grossier R, Hammadi Z, Morin R, Magnaldo A, Veesler S 2011. Generating nanoliter to femtoliter microdroplets with ease. Appl. Phys. Lett. 98:091916
     [Google Scholar]