1932
0
  1. Home
  2. A-Z Publications
  3. Annual Review of Condensed Matter Physics
  4. Volume 13, 2022
  5. Article

Annual Review of Condensed Matter Physics

Volume 13, 2022

Active Turbulence

Abstract

Active fluids exhibit spontaneous flows with complex spatiotemporal structure, which have been observed in bacterial suspensions, sperm cells, cytoskeletal suspensions, self-propelled colloids, and cell tissues. Despite occurring in the absence of inertia, chaotic active flows are reminiscent of inertial turbulence, and hence they are known as active turbulence. Here, we survey the field, providing a unified perspective over different classes of active turbulence. To this end, we divide our review into sections for systems with either polar or nematic order, and with or without momentum conservation (wet or dry). Comparing to inertial turbulence, we highlight the emergence of power-law scaling with either universal or nonuniversal exponents. We also contrast scenarios for the transition from steady to chaotic flows, and we discuss the absence of energy cascades. We link this feature to both the existence of intrinsic length scales and the self-organized nature of energy injection in active turbulence, which are fundamental differences from inertial turbulence. We close by outlining the emerging picture, remaining challenges, and future directions.

Keyword(s): active fluids, energy cascade, scaling laws, spatiotemporal chaos, topological defects, universality
Loading

Article metrics loading...

/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-conmatphys-082321-035957
2022-03-10
2024-04-18
Loading full text...

Full text loading...

/deliver/fulltext/conmatphys/13/1/annurev-conmatphys-082321-035957.html?itemId=/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-conmatphys-082321-035957&mimeType=html&fmt=ahah

Literature Cited

  1. 1. 
    Frisch U. 1995. Turbulence. The legacy of A.N. Kolmogorov Cambridge, UK: Cambridge Univ. Press
  2. 2. 
    Rose H, Sulem P. 1978. J. Phys. 39:441–84
  3. 3. 
    Falkovich G, Sreenivasan KR. 2006. Phys. Today 59:43–49
  4. 4. 
    Kolmogorov AN. 1991. Proc. R. Soc. A Math. Phys. Eng. Sci. 434:9–13
  5. 5. 
    Kraichnan RH, Montgomery D. 1980. Rep. Prog. Phys. 43:547–619
  6. 6. 
    Boffetta G, Ecke RE. 2012. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 44:427–51
  7. 7. 
    Groisman A, Steinberg V. 2000. Nature 405:53–55
  8. 8. 
    Groisman A, Steinberg V. 2001. Nature 410:905–8
  9. 9. 
    Steinberg V. 2019. Phys. Rev. Lett. 123:234501
  10. 10. 
    Dombrowski C, Cisneros L, Chatkaew S, Goldstein RE, Kessler JO. 2004. Phys. Rev. Lett. 93:098103
  11. 11. 
    Cisneros LH, Cortez R, Dombrowski C, Goldstein RE, Kessler JO. 2007. Exp. Fluids 43:737–53
  12. 12. 
    Sokolov A, Aranson IS, Kessler JO, Goldstein RE. 2007. Phys. Rev. Lett. 98:158102
  13. 13. 
    Ishikawa T, Yoshida N, Ueno H, Wiedeman M, Imai Y, Yamaguchi T. 2011. Phys. Rev. Lett. 107:028102
  14. 14. 
    Sokolov A, Aranson IS. 2012. Phys. Rev. Lett. 109:248109
  15. 15. 
    Wensink HH, Dunkel J, Heidenreich S, Drescher K, Goldstein RE et al. 2012. PNAS 109:14308–13
  16. 16. 
    Dunkel J, Heidenreich S, Drescher K, Wensink HH, Bär M, Goldstein RE. 2013. Phys. Rev. Lett. 110:228102
  17. 17. 
    Patteson AE, Gopinath A, Arratia PE. 2018. Nat. Commun. 9:5373
  18. 18. 
    Li H, Shi XQ, Huang M, Chen X, Xiao M et al. 2019. PNAS 116:777–85
  19. 19. 
    Peng Y, Liu Z, Cheng X. 2021. Sci. Adv. 7:eabd1240
  20. 20. 
    Liu Z, Zeng W, Ma X, Cheng X. 2021. 1710506–17
  21. 21. 
    Creppy A, Praud O, Druart X, Kohnke PL, Plouraboué F. 2015. Phys. Rev. E 92:032722
  22. 22. 
    Sanchez T, Chen DTN, DeCamp SJ, Heymann M, Dogic Z. 2012. Nature 491:431–34
  23. 23. 
    Henkin G, DeCamp SJ, Chen DTN, Sanchez T, Dogic Z. 2014. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. A Math. Phys. Eng. Sci. 372:20140142
  24. 24. 
    Guillamat P, Ignés-Mullol J, Sagués F. 2017. Nat. Commun. 8:564
  25. 25. 
    Lemma LM, DeCamp SJ, You Z, Giomi L, Dogic Z. 2019. Soft Matter 15:3264–72
  26. 26. 
    Martínez-Prat B, Ignés-Mullol J, Casademunt J, Sagués F. 2019. Nat. Phys. 15:362–66
  27. 27. 
    Tan AJ, Roberts E, Smith SA, Olvera UA, Arteaga J et al. 2019. Nat. Phys. 15:1033–39
  28. 28. 
    Martínez-Prat B, Alert R, Meng F, Ignés-Mullol J, Joanny JF et al. 2021. Phys. Rev. X 11:031065
  29. 29. 
    Doostmohammadi A, Thampi SP, Saw TB, Lim CT, Ladoux B, Yeomans JM. 2015. Soft Matter 11:7328–36
  30. 30. 
    Yang TD, Kim H, Yoon C, Baek SK, Lee KJ. 2016. New J. Phys. 18:103032
  31. 31. 
    Blanch-Mercader C, Yashunsky V, Garcia S, Duclos G, Giomi L, Silberzan P. 2018. Phys. Rev. Lett. 120:208101
  32. 32. 
    Lin SZ, Zhang WY, Bi D, Li B, Feng XQ. 2021. Commun. Phys. 4:21
  33. 33. 
    Nishiguchi D, Sano M. 2015. Phys. Rev. E 92:052309
  34. 34. 
    Karani H, Pradillo GE, Vlahovska PM. 2019. Phys. Rev. Lett. 123:208002
  35. 35. 
    Marchetti MC, Joanny JF, Ramaswamy S, Liverpool TB, Prost J et al. 2013. Rev. Mod. Phys. 85:1143–89
  36. 36. 
    Thampi SP, Yeomans JM. 2016. Eur. Phys. J. Spec. Top. 225:651–62
  37. 37. 
    Drescher K, Dunkel J, Cisneros LH, Ganguly S, Goldstein RE. 2011. PNAS 108:10940–45
  38. 38. 
    Koch DL, Subramanian G. 2011. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 43:637–59
  39. 39. 
    Blanch-Mercader C, Vincent R, Bazellières E, Serra-Picamal X, Trepat X, Casademunt J. 2017. Soft Matter 13:1235–43
  40. 40. 
    Duclos G, Blanch-Mercader C, Yashunsky V, Salbreux G, Joanny JF et al. 2018. Nat. Phys. 14:728–32
  41. 41. 
    Pérez-González C, Alert R, Blanch-Mercader C, Gómez-González M, Kolodziej T et al. 2019. Nat. Phys. 15:79–88
  42. 42. 
    Saffman PG, Delbrück M. 1975. PNAS 72:3111–13
  43. 43. 
    Maitra A, Srivastava P, Marchetti MC, Ramaswamy S, Lenz M. 2020. Phys. Rev. Lett. 124:028002
  44. 44. 
    Bricard A, Caussin JB, Desreumaux N, Dauchot O, Bartolo D. 2013. Nature 503:95–98
  45. 45. 
    Narayan V, Ramaswamy S, Menon N. 2007. Science 317:105–8
  46. 46. 
    Kumar N, Zhang R, de Pablo JJ, Gardel ML. 2018. Sci. Adv. 4:eaat7779
  47. 47. 
    Zhang R, Kumar N, Ross JL, Gardel ML, de Pablo JJ. 2018. PNAS 115:E124–33
  48. 48. 
    Loiseau E, Gsell S, Nommick A, Jomard C, Gras D et al. 2020. Nat. Phys. 16:1158–64
  49. 49. 
    Copenhagen K, Alert R, Wingreen NS, Shaevitz JW. 2021. Nat. Phys. 17:211–15
  50. 50. 
    Aranson IS, Sokolov A, Kessler JO, Goldstein RE. 2007. Phys. Rev. E 75:040901
  51. 51. 
    Wolgemuth CW. 2008. Biophys. J. 95:1564–74
  52. 52. 
    Bär M, Großmann R, Heidenreich S, Peruani F. 2020. Annu. Rev. Condens. Matter Phys. 11:441–66
  53. 53. 
    Großmann R, Romanczuk P, Bär M, Schimansky-Geier L. 2014. Phys. Rev. Lett. 113:258104
  54. 54. 
    Dunkel J, Heidenreich S, Bär M, Goldstein RE. 2013. New J. Phys. 15:045016
  55. 55. 
    Bratanov V, Jenko F, Frey E. 2015. PNAS 112:15048–53
  56. 56. 
    James M, Bos WJT, Wilczek M. 2018. Phys. Rev. Fluids 3:061101
  57. 57. 
    James M, Wilczek M. 2018. Eur. Phys. J. E 41:21
  58. 58. 
    Heidenreich S, Dunkel J, Klapp SHL, Bär M. 2016. Phys. Rev. E 94:020601
  59. 59. 
    Reinken H, Klapp SHL, Bär M, Heidenreich S. 2018. Phys. Rev. E 97:022613
  60. 60. 
    Toner J, Tu Y. 1995. Phys. Rev. Lett. 75:4326–29
  61. 61. 
    Toner J, Tu Y, Ramaswamy S. 2005. Ann. Phys. (N. Y.) 318:170–244
     [Google Scholar]
  62. 62. 
    Vicsek T, Czirók A, Ben-Jacob E, Cohen I, Shochet O. 1995. Phys. Rev. Lett. 75:1226–29
  63. 63. 
    Hatwalne Y, Ramaswamy S, Rao M, Simha R. 2004. Phys. Rev. Lett. 92:118101
  64. 64. 
    Sokolov A, Aranson I. 2009. Phys. Rev. Lett. 103:148101
  65. 65. 
    Giomi L, Liverpool TB, Marchetti MC. 2010. Phys. Rev. E 81:051908
  66. 66. 
    Ramaswamy S. 2010. Annu. Rev. Condens. Matter Phys. 1:323–45
  67. 67. 
    Gachelin J, Miño G, Berthet H, Lindner A, Rousselet A, Clément É. 2013. Phys. Rev. Lett. 110:268103
  68. 68. 
    López HM, Gachelin J, Douarche C, Auradou H, Clément E. 2015. Phys. Rev. Lett. 115:028301
  69. 69. 
    Saintillan D. 2018. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 50:563–92
  70. 70. 
    Swift J, Hohenberg P. 1977. Phys. Rev. A 15:319–28
  71. 71. 
    Cross M, Hohenberg P. 1993. Rev. Mod. Phys. 65:851–1112
  72. 72. 
    Zhang J, Alert R, Yan J, Wingreen NS, Granick S. 2021. Nat. Phys. 17:961–67
  73. 73. 
    Kim JH, Serra-Picamal X, Tambe DT, Zhou EH, Park CY et al. 2013. Nat. Mater. 12:856–63
  74. 74. 
    Notbohm J, Banerjee S, Utuje KJ, Gweon B, Jang H et al. 2016. Biophys. J. 110:2729–38
  75. 75. 
    Alert R, Trepat X. 2020. Annu. Rev. Condens. Matter Phys. 11:77–101
  76. 76. 
    Blanch-Mercader C, Casademunt J. 2017. Soft Matter 13:6913–28
  77. 77. 
    de Gennes PG, Prost J. 1993. The Physics of Liquid Crystals Oxford, UK: Oxford Univ. Press. , 2nd ed..
  78. 78. 
    Prost J, Jülicher F, Joanny JF. 2015. Nat. Phys. 11:111–17
  79. 79. 
    Jülicher F, Grill SW, Salbreux G. 2018. Rep. Prog. Phys. 81:076601
  80. 80. 
    Aranson IS, Kramer L. 2002. Rev. Mod. Phys. 74:99–143
  81. 81. 
    Chate H. 1994. Nonlinearity 7:185–204
  82. 82. 
    Marcq P. 2014. Eur. Phys. J. E 37:29
  83. 83. 
    Słomka J, Dunkel J. 2015. Eur. Phys. J. Spec. Top. 224:1349–58
  84. 84. 
    Aranson IS, Tsimring LS. 2006. Rev. Mod. Phys. 78:641–92
  85. 85. 
    Słomka J, Dunkel J. 2017. PNAS 114:2119–24
  86. 86. 
    Słomka J, Dunkel J. 2017. Phys. Rev. Fluids 2:043102
  87. 87. 
    Mickelin O, Słomka J, Burns KJ, Lecoanet D, Vasil GM et al. 2018. Phys. Rev. Lett. 120:164503
  88. 88. 
    Słomka J, Suwara P, Dunkel J. 2018. J. Fluid Mech. 841:702–31
  89. 89. 
    Linkmann M, Boffetta G, Marchetti MC, Eckhardt B. 2019. Phys. Rev. Lett. 122:214503
  90. 90. 
    Linkmann M, Marchetti MC, Boffetta G, Eckhardt B. 2020. Phys. Rev. E 101:022609
  91. 91. 
    Kokot G, Das S, Winkler RG, Gompper G, Aranson IS, Snezhko A. 2017. PNAS 114:12870–75
  92. 92. 
    Bourgoin M, Kervil R, Cottin-Bizonne C, Raynal F, Volk R, Ybert C. 2020. Phys. Rev. X 10:021065
  93. 93. 
    Bonelli F, Gonnella G, Tiribocchi A, Marenduzzo D. 2016. Eur. Phys. J. E. 39:1
  94. 94. 
    Chatterjee R, Rana N, Simha RA, Perlekar P, Ramaswamy S. 2021. Phys. Rev. X 11:031063
  95. 95. 
    Giomi L, Marchetti MC, Liverpool TB. 2008. Phys. Rev. Lett. 101:198101
  96. 96. 
    Tjhung E, Cates ME, Marenduzzo D. 2011. Soft Matter 7:7453–64
  97. 97. 
    Giomi L, Marchetti MC. 2012. Soft Matter 8:129–39
  98. 98. 
    Tu Y, Toner J, Ulm M. 1998. Phys. Rev. Lett. 80:4819–22
  99. 99. 
    Bertin E, Droz M, Grégoire G. 2009. J. Phys. A Math. Theor. 42:445001
  100. 100. 
    Geyer D, Morin A, Bartolo D. 2018. Nat. Mater. 17:789–93
  101. 101. 
    Chen C, Liu S, Xq Shi, Chaté H, Wu Y. 2017. Nature 542:210–14
  102. 102. 
    Ramaswamy R, Jülicher F. 2016. Sci. Rep. 6:20838
  103. 103. 
    Giomi L, Mahadevan L, Chakraborty B, Hagan MF. 2011. Phys. Rev. Lett. 106:218101
  104. 104. 
    Carenza LN, Biferale L, Gonnella G. 2020. Phys. Rev. Fluids 5:011302
  105. 105. 
    Škultéty V, Nardini C, Stenhammar J, Marenduzzo D, Morozov A. 2020. Phys. Rev. X 10:031059
  106. 106. 
    Doostmohammadi A, Ignés-Mullol J, Yeomans JM, Sagués F. 2018. Nat. Commun. 9:3246
  107. 107. 
    Kruse K, Joanny JF, Jülicher F, Prost J, Sekimoto K. 2005. Eur. Phys. J. E 16:5–16
  108. 108. 
    Voituriez R, Joanny JF, Prost J. 2005. Europhys. Lett. 70:404–10
  109. 109. 
    Simha RA, Ramaswamy S. 2002. Phys. Rev. Lett. 89:058101
  110. 110. 
    Edwards SA, Yeomans JM. 2009. Europhys. Lett. 85:18008
  111. 111. 
    Alert R, Joanny JF, Casademunt J. 2020. Nat. Phys. 16:682–88
  112. 112. 
    Kléman M. 1989. Rep. Prog. Phys. 52:555
  113. 113. 
    Aranson IS. 2019. Physics-Uspekhi 62:892–909
  114. 114. 
    Thampi SP, Golestanian R, Yeomans JM. 2014. Europhys. Lett. 105:18001
  115. 115. 
    Thampi SP, Golestanian R, Yeomans JM. 2014. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. A Math. Phys. Eng. Sci. 372:20130366
  116. 116. 
    Giomi L, Bowick MJ, Ma X, Marchetti MC. 2013. Phys. Rev. Lett. 110:228101
  117. 117. 
    Giomi L, Bowick MJ, Mishra P, Sknepnek R, Marchetti MC. 2014. Philos. Trans. A. Math. Phys. Eng. Sci. 372:20130365
  118. 118. 
    Shankar S, Ramaswamy S, Marchetti MC, Bowick MJ. 2018. Phys. Rev. Lett. 121:108002
  119. 119. 
    Thampi SP, Golestanian R, Yeomans JM. 2013. Phys. Rev. Lett. 111:118101
  120. 120. 
    Giomi L. 2015. Phys. Rev. X 5:031003
  121. 121. 
    Fielding SM, Marenduzzo D, Cates ME. 2011. Phys. Rev. E 83:041910
  122. 122. 
    Shendruk TN, Doostmohammadi A, Thijssen K, Yeomans JM. 2017. Soft Matter 13:3853–62
  123. 123. 
    Doostmohammadi A, Yeomans JM. 2019. Eur. Phys. J. Spec. Top. 227:2401–11
  124. 124. 
    Doostmohammadi A, Shendruk TN, Thijssen K, Yeomans JM. 2017. Nat. Commun. 8:15326
  125. 125. 
    Hardoüin J, Hughes R, Doostmohammadi A, Laurent J, Lopez-Leon T et al. 2019. Commun. Phys. 2:121
  126. 126. 
    Maitra A, Srivastava P, Marchetti MC, Lintuvuori JS, Ramaswamy S, Lenz M. 2018. PNAS 115:6934–39
  127. 127. 
    Hemingway EJ, Mishra P, Marchetti MC, Fielding SM. 2016. Soft Matter 12:7943–52
  128. 128. 
    Underhill PT, Hernandez-Ortiz JP, Graham MD. 2008. Phys. Rev. Lett. 100:248101
  129. 129. 
    Bárdfalvy D, Nordanger H, Nardini C, Morozov A, Stenhammar J. 2019. Soft Matter 15:7747–56
  130. 130. 
    Worlitzer VM, Ariel G, Be'er A, Stark H, Bär M, Heidenreich S. 2021. New J. Phys. 23:033012
  131. 131. 
    Urzay J, Doostmohammadi A, Yeomans JM. 2017. J. Fluid Mech. 822:762–73
  132. 132. 
    Carenza LN, Biferale L, Gonnella G. 2020. Europhys. Lett. 132:44003
  133. 133. 
    Chaté H. 2020. Annu. Rev. Condens. Matter Phys. 11:189–212
  134. 134. 
    Ngo S, Peshkov A, Aranson IS, Bertin E, Ginelli F, Chaté H. 2014. Phys. Rev. Lett. 113:038302
  135. 135. 
    Putzig E, Redner GS, Baskaran A, Baskaran A. 2016. Soft Matter 12:3854–59
  136. 136. 
    Maryshev I, Goryachev AB, Marenduzzo D, Morozov A. 2019. Soft Matter 15:6038–43
  137. 137. 
    Patelli A, Djafer-Cherif I, Aranson IS, Bertin E, Chaté H. 2019. Phys. Rev. Lett. 123:258001
  138. 138. 
    Kawaguchi K, Kageyama R, Sano M. 2017. Nature 545:327–31
  139. 139. 
    Thijssen K, Metselaar L, Yeomans JM, Doostmohammadi A. 2020. Soft Matter 16:2065–74
  140. 140. 
    Guillamat P, Ignés-Mullol J, Sagués F. 2016. PNAS 113:5498–502
  141. 141. 
    Thampi SP, Golestanian R, Yeomans JM. 2014. Phys. Rev. E 90:062307
  142. 142. 
    Doostmohammadi A, Adamer MF, Thampi SP, Yeomans JM. 2016. Nat. Commun. 7:10557
  143. 143. 
    Srivastava P, Mishra P, Marchetti MC. 2016. Soft Matter 12:8214–25
  144. 144. 
    Oza AU, Dunkel J. 2016. New J. Phys. 18:093006
  145. 145. 
    Oza AU, Heidenreich S, Dunkel J. 2016. Eur. Phys. J. E 39:97
  146. 146. 
    Coelho RCV, Araújo NAM, Telo da Gama MM. 2020. Soft Matter 16:4256–66
  147. 147. 
    Thijssen K, Nejad MR, Yeomans JM. 2020. Phys. Rev. Lett. 125:218004
  148. 148. 
    DeCamp SJ, Redner GS, Baskaran A, Hagan MF, Dogic Z. 2015. Nat. Mater. 14:1110–15
  149. 149. 
    Pearce DJG, Nambisan J, Ellis PW, Fernandez-Nieves A, Giomi L. 2021. Phys. Rev. Lett 127197801
  150. 150. 
    Shankar S, Marchetti MC. 2019. Phys. Rev. X 9:041047
  151. 151. 
    Thijssen K, Khaladj D, Aghvami SA, Gharbi MA, Fraden S et al. 2021. PNAS 118:38e2106038118
  152. 152. 
    Guillamat P, Ignés-Mullol J, Shankar S, Marchetti MC, Sagués F. 2016. Phys. Rev. E 94:060602
  153. 153. 
    Qiu X, Ding L, Huang Y, Chen M, Lu Z et al. 2016. Phys. Rev. E 93:062226
  154. 154. 
    Wang L, Huang Y. 2017. Phys. Rev. E 95:052215
  155. 155. 
    Hashemi A, Ejtehadi MR. 2021. Soft Mater. 19:316–22
  156. 156. 
    Ellis PW, Pearce DJG, Chang YW, Goldsztein G, Giomi L, Fernandez-Nieves A. 2018. Nat. Phys. 14:85–90
  157. 157. 
    Duclos G, Adkins R, Banerjee D, Peterson MSE, Varghese M et al. 2020. Science 367:1120–24
  158. 158. 
    Shendruk TN, Thijssen K, Yeomans JM, Doostmohammadi A. 2018. Phys. Rev. E 98:010601
  159. 159. 
    Čopar S, Aplinc J, Kos Ž, Žumer S, Ravnik M. 2019. Phys. Rev. X 9:031051
  160. 160. 
    Binysh J, Kos Ž, Čopar S, Ravnik M, Alexander GP. 2020. Phys. Rev. Lett. 124:088001
  161. 161. 
    Krajnik Ž, Kos Ž, Ravnik M. 2020. Soft Matter 16:9059–68
  162. 162. 
    Carenza LN, Gonnella G, Marenduzzo D, Negro G. 2019. PNAS 116:22065–70
  163. 163. 
    Needleman D, Shelley M. 2019. Phys. Today 72:32–38
  164. 164. 
    Nishikawa M, Naganathan SR, Jülicher F, Grill SW. 2017. eLife 6:e19595
  165. 165. 
    Sanjay CP, Joy A. 2020. Phys. Rev. Fluids 5:024302
  166. 166. 
    Mukherjee S, Singh RK, James M, Ray SS. 2021. Phys. Rev. Lett. 127:118001
  167. 167. 
    Hemingway EJ, Maitra A, Banerjee S, Marchetti MC, Ramaswamy S et al. 2015. Phys. Rev. Lett. 114:098302
  168. 168. 
    Hemingway EJ, Cates ME, Fielding SM. 2016. Phys. Rev. E 93:032702
  169. 169. 
    Liu S, Shankar S, Marchetti MC, Wu Y. 2021. Nature 590:80–84
  170. 170. 
    Tan TH, Liu J, Miller PW, Tekant M, Dunkel J, Fakhri N. 2020. Nat. Phys. 16:657–62
/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-conmatphys-082321-035957
Loading
Active Turbulence
Annual Review of Condensed Matter Physics 13, 143 (2022); https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-conmatphys-082321-035957
/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-conmatphys-082321-035957
/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-conmatphys-082321-035957
Loading

Data & Media loading...

  • Article Type: Review Article

Most Cited Most Cited RSS feed

This is a required field
Please enter a valid email address
Approval was a Success
Invalid data
An Error Occurred
Approval was partially successful, following selected items could not be processed due to error