This article examines market liquidity in the postcrisis era in light of concerns that regulatory changes might have reduced dealers’ ability and willingness to make markets. We begin with a discussion of the broader trading environment, including an overview of regulations and their potential effects on dealer balance sheets and market making, but also considering additional drivers of market liquidity. We document a stagnation of dealer balance sheets after the financial crisis of 2007–2009, which occurred concurrently with dealer balance sheet deleveraging. However, using high-frequency trade and quote data for US Treasuries and corporate bonds, we find only limited evidence of a deterioration in market liquidity.


Article metrics loading...

Loading full text...

Full text loading...


Literature Cited

  1. Adrian T, Boyarchenko N, Shachar O. 2017. Dealer balance sheets and bond liquidity provision. J. Monet. Econ. 89:92–109 [Google Scholar]
  2. Adrian T, Crump RK, Moench E. 2013. Pricing the term structure with linear regressions. J. Financ. Econ. 110:1110–38 [Google Scholar]
  3. Adrian T, Fleming M. 2013. The recent bond market selloff in historical perspective. Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y. Liberty Street Economics Aug. 5. http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2013/08/the-recent-bond-market-selloff-in-historical-perspective.html
  4. Adrian T, Fleming M, Goldberg J, Lewis M, Natalucci F, Wu J. 2013. Dealer balance sheet capacity and market liquidity during the 2013 selloff in fixed-income markets. Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y. Liberty Street Economics Oct. 21. http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2013/10/dealer-balance-sheet-capacity-and-market-liquidity-during-the-2013-selloff-in-fixed-income-markets.html
  5. Adrian T, Fleming M, Shachar O, Stackman D, Vogt E. 2015a. Changes in the returns to market making. Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y. Liberty Street Economics Oct. 7. http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2015/10/changes-in-the-returns-to-market-making.html
  6. Adrian T, Fleming M, Shachar O, Stackman D, Vogt E. 2015b. Has liquidity risk in the corporate bond market increased?. Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y. Liberty Street Economics Oct. 6. http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2015/10/has-liquidity-risk-in-the-corporate-bond-market-increased.html.
  7. Adrian T, Fleming M, Shachar O, Vogt E. 2015c. Has US corporate bond market liquidity deteriorated?. Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y. Liberty Street Economics Oct. 5. http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2015/10/has-us-corporate-bond-market-liquidity-deteriorated.html
  8. Adrian T, Fleming M, Shachar O, Vogt E. 2015d. Redemption risk of bond mutual funds and dealer positioning. Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y. Liberty Street Economics Oct. 8. http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2015/10/redemption-risk-of-bond-mutual-funds-and-dealer-positioning.html.
  9. Adrian T, Fleming M, Stackman D, Vogt E. 2015e. Has liquidity risk in the Treasury and equity markets increased?. Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y. Liberty Street Economics Oct. 6. http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2015/10/has-liquidity-risk-in-the-treasury-and-equity-markets-increased.html
  10. Adrian T, Fleming M, Stackman D, Vogt E. 2015f. Has US Treasury market liquidity deteriorated?. Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y. Liberty Street Economics Aug. 17. http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2015/08/has-us-treasury-market-liquidity-deteriorated.html
  11. Adrian T, Fleming M, Stackman D, Vogt E. 2015g. What's driving dealer balance sheet stagnation?. Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y. Liberty Street Economics Aug. 21. http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2015/08/whats-driving-dealer-balance-sheet-stagnation.html
  12. Adrian T, Fleming M, Vogt E. 2015. Dealer positioning and expected returns. Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y. Liberty Street Economics Dec. 7. http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2015/12/dealer-positioning-and-expected-returns.html
  13. Adrian T, Fleming M, Vogt E, Wojtowicz Z. 2016a. Corporate bond market liquidity redux: more price-based evidence. Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y. Liberty Street Economics Feb. 9. http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2016/02/corporate-bond-market-liquidity-redux-more-price-based-evidence.html
  14. Adrian T, Fleming M, Vogt E, Wojtowicz Z. 2016b. Did Third Avenue's liquidation reduce corporate bond market liquidity?. Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y. Liberty Street Economics Feb. 19. http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2016/02/did-third-avenues-liquidation-reduce-corporate-bond-market-liquidity.html
  15. Adrian T, Fleming M, Wojtowicz Z, Vogt E. 2016c. Further analysis of corporate bond market liquidity. Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y. Liberty Street Economics Feb. 10. http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2016/02/further-analysis-of-corporate-bond-market-liquidity.html
  16. Adrian T, Shin HS. 2010. Liquidity and leverage. J. Financ. Intermed. 19:3418–37 [Google Scholar]
  17. Adrian T, Shin HS. 2014. Procyclical leverage and value-at-risk. Rev. Financ. Stud. 27:2373–403 [Google Scholar]
  18. Amihud Y. 2002. Illiquidity and stock returns: cross-section and time-series effects. J. Financ. Markets 5:131–56 [Google Scholar]
  19. Amihud Y, Mendelson H. 1986. Asset pricing and the bid-ask spread. J. Financ. Econ. 17:2223–49 [Google Scholar]
  20. Anderson M, Stulz RM. 2017. Is post-crisis bond liquidity lower? NBER Work. Pap 23317
  21. Bao J, O'Hara M, Zhou X. 2016. The Volcker rule and market-making in times of stress Work. Pap., Fed. Reserve Board, Washington, DC
  22. Barclays 2016. Behavior modification Barclays Credit Res New York:
  23. BCBS (Basel Comm. Bank. Superv.) 2010. Revisions to the Basel II Market Risk Framework Basel, Switz.: BCBS
  24. BCBS (Basel Comm. Bank. Superv.) 2011. Basel III: A Global Regulatory Framework for More Resilient Banks and Banking Systems Basel, Switz.: BCBS
  25. BCBS (Basel Comm. Bank. Superv.) 2013a. Basel III: The Liquidity Coverage Ratio and Liquidity Risk Monitoring Tools. Basel, Switz.: BCBS
  26. BCBS (Basel Comm. Bank. Superv.) 2013b. Global Systemically Important Banks: Updated Assessment Methodology and the Higher Loss Absorbency Requirement Basel, Switz.: BCBS
  27. BCBS (Basel Comm. Bank. Superv.) 2014. Basel III: The Net Stable Funding Ratio. Basel, Switz: BCBS
  28. Bessembinder H, Jacobsen S, Maxwell W, Venkataraman K. 2016. Capital commitment and illiquidity in corporate bonds. Work. Pap., South. Methodist Univ., Dallas
  29. Biais B, Foucault T, Moinas S. 2015. Equilibrium fast trading. J. Financ. Econ. 116:2292–313 [Google Scholar]
  30. BIS (Bank Int. Settl.) 2016. Electronic trading in fixed income markets Rep., Markets Comm., BIS, Basel, Switz.
  31. Bloomberg 2016a. Cracks exposed in US bond market as liquidity woes warp prices. Bloomberg News Jan 25
  32. Bloomberg 2016b. US Treasury sees bond liquidity, but not as we know it. Bloomberg News July 7
  33. Boni L, Leach C. 2004. Expandable limit order markets. J. Financ. Markets 7:2145–85 [Google Scholar]
  34. Boyarchenko N, Gupta P, Steele N, Yen J. 2016. Trends in credit market arbitrage Staff Rep. 784, Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y.
  35. Brunnermeier MK, Pedersen LH. 2009. Market liquidity and funding liquidity. Rev. Financ. Stud. 22:62201–38 [Google Scholar]
  36. Budish E, Cramton P, Shim J. 2015. The high-frequency trading arms race: frequent batch auctions as a market design response. Q. J. Econ. 130:41547–621 [Google Scholar]
  37. Cameron M, Becker L. 2013. The great unwind: buy-side fears impact of market-making constraints. Risk July 30
  38. CFTC (Commod. Futures Trading Comm.), SEC (Secur. Exch. Comm.) 2010. Findings regarding the market events of May 6, 2010 Staff Rep., CFTC, SEC, Washington, DC. https://www.sec.gov/news/studies/2010/marketevents-report.pdf
  39. CGFS (Comm. Global Financ. Syst.) 2014. Market-making and proprietary trading: industry trends, drivers and policy implications Pap. 52, CGFS, Basel, Switz.
  40. CGFS (Comm. Global Financ. Syst.) 2016. Fixed income market liquidity. Pap. 55, CGFS, Basel, Switz.
  41. Cheng I-H, Hong H, Scheinkman JA. 2015. Yesterday's heroes: compensation and risk at financial firms. J. Finance 70:2839–79 [Google Scholar]
  42. Chevalier J, Ellison G. 1999. Career concerns of mutual fund managers. Q. J. Econ. 114:2389–432 [Google Scholar]
  43. Choi J, Huh Y. 2016. Customer liquidity provision: implications for corporate bond transaction costs. Work. Pap., Div. Res. Stat., Board Gov. Fed. Reserve Syst., Washington, DC
  44. Di Maggio M, Kermani A, Song Z. 2015. The value of trading relationships in turbulent times Res. Pap., Columbia Bus. Sch.
  45. Dick-Nielsen J, Feldhütter P, Lando D. 2012. Corporate bond liquidity before and after the onset of the subprime crisis. J. Financ. Econ. 103:3471–92 [Google Scholar]
  46. Dick-Nielsen J, Rossi M. 2016. The cost of immediacy for corporate bonds Work. Pap., Copenhagen Bus. Sch.
  47. Dobrev D, Schaumburg E. 2015. The liquidity mirage. Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y. Liberty Street Economics, Oct. 15. http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2015/10/the-liquidity-mirage-.html
  48. Dudley W. 2016. Market and funding liquidity: an overview Remarks at Fed. Reserve Bank Atlanta Financ. Markets Conf., May 1–3 Amelia Island, FL
  49. Duffie D. 2012. Market making under the proposed Volcker rule Work. Pap. 106, Rock Cent. Corp. Gov., Stanford Univ.
  50. Edwards A, Harris L, Piwowar M. 2007. Corporate bond market transaction costs and transparency. J. Finance 62:31421–51 [Google Scholar]
  51. Engle RF, Fleming MJ, Ghysels E, Nguyen G. 2012. Liquidity, volatility, and flights to safety in the US treasury market: evidence from a new class of dynamic order book models Staff Rep. 590, Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y.
  52. Feroli M, Kashyap A, Schoenholtz K, Shin HS. 2014. Market tantrums and monetary policy Res. Pap. 14-09, Booth Sch. Bus., Univ. Chic.
  53. Fleming M. 1997. The round-the-clock market for US Treasury securities. Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y. Econ. Policy Rev. 3:29–32 [Google Scholar]
  54. Fleming M. 2000. The benchmark US Treasury market: recent performance and possible alternatives. Fed. Reserve Bank Econ. Policy Rev. 6:1129–45 [Google Scholar]
  55. Fleming M, Keane F, Schaumburg E. 2016. Primary dealer participation in the secondary US Treasury market. Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y. Liberty Street Economics Feb. 12. http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2016/02/primary-dealer-participation-in-the-secondary-us-treasury-market.html
  56. Fleming M, Mizrach B, Nguyen G. 2017. The microstructure of a US Treasury ECN: the BrokerTec platform. J. Financ. Markets. press
  57. Fleming M, Nguyen G. 2013. Order flow segmentation and the role of dark trading in the price discovery of U.S. Treasury securities. Staff Rep. 624, Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y. [Google Scholar]
  58. FSB (Financ. Stab. Board) 2015. Principles on Loss-absorbing and Recapitalisation Capacity of G-SIBs in Resolution FSB: Basel, Switz.
  59. FSOC (Financ. Stab. Overs. Counc.) 2013. 2013 Annual Report Washington, DC: FSOC
  60. Goldstein I, Jiang H, Ng D. 2015. Investor flows and fragility in corporate bond funds Work. Pap., Wharton Sch., Univ. Pa.
  61. Grossman S, Miller M. 1988. Liquidity and market structure. J. Finance 43:3617–33 [Google Scholar]
  62. Gürkaynak RS, Sack B, Wright JH. 2007. The US Treasury yield curve: 1961 to the present. J. Monet. Econ. 54:82291–304 [Google Scholar]
  63. Hasbrouck J, Saar G. 2013. Low latency trading. J. Financ. Markets 16:646–79 [Google Scholar]
  64. Hendershott T, Jones C, Menkveld A. 2011. Does algorithmic trading improve liquidity?. J. Finance 66:1–33 [Google Scholar]
  65. Hu GX, Pan J, Wang J. 2013. Noise as information for illiquidity. J. Finance 68:62341–82 [Google Scholar]
  66. Staff Joint. 2015. The US Treasury market on October 15, 2014 Joint Staff Rep., U.S. Dep. Treas., Board Gov. Fed. Reserve Syst., Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y., U.S. Secur. Exch. Commis., U.S. Commod. Futures Trad. Commis. https://www.treasury.gov/press-center/press-releases/Documents/Joint_Staff_Report_Treasury_10-15-2015.pdf
  67. Jones C. 2013. What do we know about high-frequency trading? Res. Pap. 13–11 Columbia Bus. Sch.
  68. Khandani A, Lo A. 2007. What happened to the quants in August 2007? (Digest summary). J. Invest. Manag. 5:429–78 [Google Scholar]
  69. Krouse S. 2015a. Wall Street bemoans bond market liquidity squeeze. Wall Street Journal June 2
  70. Krouse S. 2015b. Who will fare best in a bond-market liquidity crunch?. Wall Street Journal July 1
  71. Kyle AS. 1985. Continuous auctions and insider trading. Econometrica 53:1315–35 [Google Scholar]
  72. Levine M. 2015. People are worried about bond market liquidity. Bloomberg ViewJune 3
  73. Longstaff FA. 2004. The flight-to-liquidity premium in US Treasury bond prices. J. Bus. 77:3511–26 [Google Scholar]
  74. Marriage M, Mooney A. 2016. Crunch elevates bond traders. Financial Times March 20
  75. Menkveld A. 2013. High frequency trading and the new market makers. J. Financ. Markets 16:4712–40 [Google Scholar]
  76. Menkveld A. 2016. The economics of high-frequency trading: taking stock. Annu. Rev. Financ. Econ. 8:1–24 [Google Scholar]
  77. Mizrach B. 2015. Analysis of corporate bond liquidity. Res. Note, Off. Chief Econ., Financ. Ind. Regul. Auth., Washington, DC
  78. Nagel S. 2012. Evaporating liquidity. Rev. Financ. Stud. 25:72005–39 [Google Scholar]
  79. Schaumburg E, Yang R. 2015. Liquidity during flash events. Fed. Reserve Bank N.Y. Liberty Street Economics Aug. 18 http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2015/08/liquidity-during-flash-events.html
  80. Sommer P, Pasquali S. 2016. Liquidity—how to capture a multidimensional beast. J. Trad. 11:221–39 [Google Scholar]
  81. Stein J. 2013. Overheating in credit markets: origins, measurement, and policy responses. Speech at Res. Symp., Restoring Household Financial Stability After the Great Recession: Why Household Balance Sheets Matter, Feb. 7, St. Louis, MO
  82. Trebbi F, Xiao K. 2015. Regulation and market liquidity NBER Work. Pap 21739
  83. Wigglesworth R. 2015. Bond market liquidity dominates conversation. Financial Times June 12

Data & Media loading...

  • Article Type: Review Article
This is a required field
Please enter a valid email address
Approval was a Success
Invalid data
An Error Occurred
Approval was partially successful, following selected items could not be processed due to error