1932

Abstract

The proliferation of government policies to manage immigration has led to the emergence of an interdisciplinary literature that evaluates policy effects on immigrant integration. This review synthesizes findings from evaluations of policies regulating legal status and citizenship, the labor market, welfare, settlement, education, and cultural rights. It concludes that policies lowering immigrants’ costs of adjustment to the host country are consistently more effective in promoting integration than policies incentivizing immigrant effort through withholding resources and regulating access to rights. Policy changes the behavior of both immigrants and native-born citizens through material and psychological pathways, and considering the decision making of each side and their interdependence is crucial for understanding why estimated effects of the same policy differ across contexts and for anticipating unintended consequences. For external validity and useful counterfactuals, a closer connection is needed between empirical research and theoretical models that explicitly account for the equilibrium nature of integration.

Loading

Article metrics loading...

/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-polisci-051921-102651
2024-07-29
2025-02-12
Loading full text...

Full text loading...

/deliver/fulltext/polisci/27/1/annurev-polisci-051921-102651.html?itemId=/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-polisci-051921-102651&mimeType=html&fmt=ahah

Literature Cited

  1. Abdelgadir A, Fouka V. 2020.. Political secularism and Muslim integration in the West: assessing the effects of the French headscarf ban. . Am. Political Sci. Rev. 114:(3):70723
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  2. Acharya A, Bansak K, Hainmueller J. 2022.. Combining outcome-based and preference-based matching: a constrained priority mechanism. . Political Anal. 30:(1):89112
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  3. Adida CL, Laitin DD, Valfort MA. 2014.. Muslims in France: identifying a discriminatory equilibrium. . J. Popul. Econ. 27::103986
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  4. Alarian HM, Neureiter M. 2021.. Values or origin? Mandatory immigrant integration and immigration attitudes in Europe. . J. Ethnic Migr. Stud. 47:(5):100627
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  5. Amuedo-Dorantes C, Antman F. 2017.. Schooling and labor market effects of temporary authorization: evidence from DACA. . J. Popul. Econ. 30::33973
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  6. Amuedo-Dorantes C, Bansak C, Raphael S. 2007.. Gender differences in the labor market: impact of IRCA's amnesty provisions. . Am. Econ. Rev. 97:(2):41216
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  7. Andersen LH, Dustmann C, Landersø RK, et al. 2019.. Lowering welfare benefits: intended and unintended consequences for migrants and their families. Study Pap. 138 , Rockwool Found., Copenhagen, Den.:
    [Google Scholar]
  8. Arendt JN, Bolvig I, Foged M, Hasager L, Peri G. 2020.. Language training and refugees’ integration. NBER Work. Pap. 26834
    [Google Scholar]
  9. Arendt JN, Dustmann C, Ku H. 2021.. Permanent residency and refugee immigrants’ skill investment. Study Pap. 161 , Rockwool Found., Copenhagen, Den.:
    [Google Scholar]
  10. Arendt JN, Dustmann C, Ku H. 2022.. Refugee migration and the labour market: lessons from 40 years of post-arrival policies in Denmark. . Oxf. Rev. Econ. Policy 38:(3):53156
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  11. Avitabile C, Clots-Figueras I, Masella P. 2013.. The effect of birthright citizenship on parental integration outcomes. . J. Law Econ. 56:(3):777810
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  12. Avitabile C, Clots-Figueras I, Masella P. 2014.. Citizenship, fertility, and parental investments. . Am. Econ. J. Appl. Econ. 6:(4):3565
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  13. Bahar D, Ibáñez AM, Rozo SV. 2021.. Give me your tired and your poor: impact of a large-scale amnesty program for undocumented refugees. . J. Dev. Econ. 151::102652
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  14. Bansak K, Ferwerda J, Hainmueller J, Dillon A, Hangartner D, et al. 2018.. Improving refugee integration through data-driven algorithmic assignment. . Science 359:(6373):32529
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  15. Battisti M, Giesing Y, Laurentsyeva N. 2019.. Can job search assistance improve the labour market integration of refugees? Evidence from a field experiment. . Labour Econ. 61::101745
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  16. Bisin A, Verdier T. 2001.. The economics of cultural transmission and the dynamics of preferences. . J. Econ. Theory 97:(2):298319
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  17. Bloemraad I. 2013.. “ The great concern of government”: public policy as material and symbolic resources. . In Outsiders No More? Models of Immigrant Political Incorporation, ed. J Hochschild, J Chattopadhyay, C Gay, M Jones-Correa , pp. 195208. Oxford, UK:: Oxford Univ. Press
    [Google Scholar]
  18. Bloemraad I, Wright M. 2014.. “ Utter failure” or unity out of diversity? Debating and evaluating policies of multiculturalism. . Int. Migr. Rev. 48:(1):292334
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  19. Böcker A, Strik T. 2011.. Language and knowledge tests for permanent residence rights: help or hindrance for integration?. Eur. J. Migr. Law 13:(2):15784
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  20. Carciotto S. 2021.. Making asylum seekers more vulnerable in South Africa: the negative effects of hostile asylum policies on livelihoods. . Int. Migr. 59:(5):318
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  21. Card D, Kluve J, Weber A. 2018.. What works? A meta analysis of recent active labor market program evaluations. . J. Eur. Econ. Assoc. 16:(3):894931
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  22. Carlana M, La Ferrara E, Pinotti P. 2022.. Goals and gaps: educational careers of immigrant children. . Econometrica 90:(1):129
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  23. Carol S, Helbling M, Michalowski I. 2015.. A struggle over religious rights? How Muslim immigrants and Christian natives view the accommodation of religion in six European countries. . Soc. Forces 94:(2):64771
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  24. Carvalho JP. 2013.. Veiling. . Q. J. Econ. 128:(1):33770
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  25. Cascio EU, Lewis EG. 2019.. Distributing the green (cards): permanent residency and personal income taxes after the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986. . J. Public Econ. 172::13550
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  26. Chin A, Daysal NM, Imberman SA. 2013.. Impact of bilingual education programs on limited English proficient students and their peers: regression discontinuity evidence from Texas. . J. Public Econ. 107::6378
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  27. Chin A, Juhn C. 2010.. Does reducing college costs improve educational outcomes for undocumented immigrants? Evidence from state laws permitting undocumented immigrants to pay in-state tuition at state colleges and universities. . In Latinos and the Economy: Integration and Impact in Schools, Labor Markets, and Beyond, ed. DL Leal, SJ Trejo , pp. 6394. New York:: Springer
    [Google Scholar]
  28. Condon M, Filindra A, Wichowsky A. 2016.. Immigrant inclusion in the safety net: a framework for analysis and effects on educational attainment. . Policy Stud. J. 44:(4):42448
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  29. Corekcioglu G. 2021.. Unveiling the effects of a headscarf ban: evidence from municipal jobs in Turkey. . J. Comp. Econ. 49:(2):382404
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  30. Dahl GB, Felfe C, Frijters P, Rainer H. 2022.. Caught between cultures: unintended consequences of improving opportunity for immigrant girls. . Rev. Econ. Stud. 89:(5):2491528
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  31. Edin PA, Fredriksson P, Åslund O. 2003.. Ethnic enclaves and the economic success of immigrants—evidence from a natural experiment. . Q. J. Econ. 118:(1):32957
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  32. Edin PA, Fredriksson P, Åslund O. 2004.. Settlement policies and the economic success of immigrants. . J. Popul. Econ. 17::13355
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  33. Elias F, Monras J, Vázquez-Grenno J. 2022.. Understanding the effects of granting work permits to undocumented immigrants. CEPR Disc. Pap. 12726 , Cent. Econ. Policy Res., London
    [Google Scholar]
  34. Emeriau M, Hainmueller J, Hangartner D, Laitin D. 2022.. “ Welcome to France.” Can mandatory integration contracts foster immigrant integration?. SocArXiv 10.31235/osf.io/ha3jd
  35. Ersanilli EF. 2010.. Comparing Integration: Host Culture Adaption and Ethnic Retention Among Turkish Immigrants and Their Descendents in France, Germany and the Netherlands. Amsterdam:: VU Univ. Press
    [Google Scholar]
  36. Ersanilli EF, Koopmans R. 2011.. Do immigrant integration policies matter? A three-country comparison among Turkish immigrants. . West Eur. Politics 34:(2):20834
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  37. Fasani F, Frattini T, Minale L. 2021.. Lift the ban? Initial employment restrictions and refugee labour market outcomes. . J. Eur. Econ. Assoc. 19:(5):280354
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  38. Fasani F, Frattini T, Minale L. 2022.. (The struggle for) refugee integration into the labour market: evidence from Europe. . J. Econ. Geogr. 22:(2):35193
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  39. Felfe C, Kocher MG, Rainer H, Saurer J, Siedler T. 2021.. More opportunity, more cooperation? The behavioral effects of birthright citizenship on immigrant youth. . J. Public Econ. 200::104448
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  40. Filindra A, Manatschal A. 2020.. Coping with a changing integration policy context: American state policies and their effects on immigrant political engagement. . Reg. Stud. 54:(11):154657
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  41. Flores RD. 2014.. Living in the eye of the storm: How did Hazleton's restrictive immigration ordinance affect local interethnic relations?. Am. Behav. Sci. 58:(13):174363
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  42. Flores SM. 2010.. State dream acts: the effect of in-state resident tuition policies and undocumented Latino students. . Rev. Higher Educ. 33:(2):23983
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  43. Foged M, Hasager L, Peri G, Arendt JN, Bolvig I. 2023.. Intergenerational spillover effects of language training for refugees. . J. Public Econ. 220::104840
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  44. Foged M, Van der Werf C. 2023.. Access to language training and the local integration of refugees. . Labour Econ. 84::102366
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  45. Fouka V. 2020.. Backlash: the unintended effects of language prohibition in US schools after World War I. . Rev. Econ. Stud. 87:(1):20439
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  46. Goodman SW. 2011.. Controlling immigration through language and country knowledge requirements. . West Eur. Politics 34:(2):23555
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  47. Goodman SW. 2012.. Fortifying citizenship: policy strategies for civic integration in Western Europe. . World Politics 64:(4):65998
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  48. Goodman SW. 2015.. Conceptualizing and measuring citizenship and integration policy: past lessons and new approaches. . Comp. Political Stud. 48:(14):190541
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  49. Goodman SW. 2023.. Citizenship studies: policy causes and consequences. . Annu. Rev. Political Sci. 26::13552
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  50. Goodman SW, Wright M. 2015.. Does mandatory integration matter? Effects of civic requirements on immigrant socio-economic and political outcomes. . J. Ethnic Migr. Stud. 41:(12):1885908
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  51. Hainmueller J, Cascardi E, Hotard M, Koslowski R, Lawrence D, et al. 2023.. Does access to citizenship confer socio-economic returns? Evidence from a randomized control design. IZA Disc. Pap. 16173 , Inst. Labor Econ., Bonn, Ger.:
    [Google Scholar]
  52. Hainmueller J, Hangartner D. 2019.. Does direct democracy hurt immigrant minorities? Evidence from naturalization decisions in Switzerland. . Am. J. Political Sci. 63:(3):53047
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  53. Hainmueller J, Hangartner D, Pietrantuono G. 2017a.. Catalyst or crown: Does naturalization promote the long-term social integration of immigrants?. Am. Political Sci. Rev. 111:(2):25676
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  54. Hainmueller J, Hangartner D, Ward D. 2019.. The effect of citizenship on the long-term earnings of marginalized immigrants: quasi-experimental evidence from Switzerland. . Sci. Adv. 5:(12):eaay1610
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  55. Hainmueller J, Lawrence D, Gest J, Hotard M, Koslowski R, Laitin DD. 2018.. A randomized controlled design reveals barriers to citizenship for low-income immigrants. . PNAS 115:(5):93944
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  56. Hainmueller J, Lawrence D, Martén L, Black B, Figueroa L, et al. 2017b.. Protecting unauthorized immigrant mothers improves their children's mental health. . Science 357:(6355):104144
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  57. Harder N, Figueroa L, Gillum RM, Hangartner D, Laitin DD, Hainmueller J. 2018.. Multidimensional measure of immigrant integration. . PNAS 115:(45):1148388
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  58. Heller B, Slungaard Mumma K. 2023.. Immigrant integration in the United States: the role of adult English language training. . Am. Econ. J. Econ. Policy 15:(3):40737
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  59. Hilbig H, Riaz S. 2022.. Freedom of movement restrictions inhibit the psychological integration of refugees. . J. Politics 84:(4):228893
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  60. Hotard M, Lawrence D, Laitin DD, Hainmueller J. 2019.. A low-cost information nudge increases citizenship application rates among low-income immigrants. . Nat. Hum. Behav. 3:(7):67883
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  61. Huynh DT, Schultz-Nielsen ML, Tranæs T. 2007.. Employment effects of reducing welfare to refugees. Study Pap. 15 , Rockwool Found., Copenhagen, Den.:
    [Google Scholar]
  62. Jiménez TR, Schildkraut DJ, Huo YJ, Dovidio JF. 2021.. States Belonging: Immigration Policies, Attitudes, and Inclusion. New York:: Russell Sage Found.
    [Google Scholar]
  63. Joona P, Nekby L. 2012.. Intensive coaching of new immigrants: an evaluation based on random program assignment. . Scand. J. Econ. 114:(2):575600
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  64. Kaushal N. 2006.. Amnesty programs and the labor market outcomes of undocumented workers. . J. Hum. Resourc. 41:(3):63147
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  65. Kaushal N. 2008.. In-state tuition for the undocumented: education effects on Mexican young adults. . J. Policy Anal. Manag. 27:(4):77192
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  66. Koopmans R. 2010.. Trade-offs between equality and difference: immigrant integration, multiculturalism and the welfare state in cross-national perspective. . J. Ethnic Migr. Stud. 36:(1):126
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  67. Koopmans R. 2013.. Multiculturalism and immigration: a contested field in cross-national comparison. . Annu. Rev. Sociol. 39::14769
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  68. Kwon R, McCaffree K. 2021.. Muslim religious accommodations in Western Europe: Do multicultural policies impact religiosity levels among Muslims, Catholics and Protestants?. Int. Migr. 59:(1):21540
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  69. Kymlicka W. 2012.. Multiculturalism: Success, Failure, and the Future. Washington, DC:: Transatlantic Counc. Migr., Migr. Policy Inst.
    [Google Scholar]
  70. Lochmann A, Rapoport H, Speciale B. 2019.. The effect of language training on immigrants’ economic integration: empirical evidence from France. . Eur. Econ. Rev. 113::26596
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  71. LoPalo M. 2019.. The effects of cash assistance on refugee outcomes. . J. Public Econ. 170::2752
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  72. Lutz P. 2017.. Two logics of policy intervention in immigrant integration: an institutionalist framework based on capabilities and aspirations. . Comp. Migr. Stud. 5:(1):118
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  73. Marbach M, Hainmueller J, Hangartner D. 2018.. The long-term impact of employment bans on the economic integration of refugees. . Sci. Adv. 4:(9):eaap9519
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  74. Massey DS, Pren KA. 2012.. Unintended consequences of US immigration policy: explaining the post-1965 surge from Latin America. . Popul. Dev. Rev. 38:(1):129
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  75. Maxwell R. 2012.. Ethnic Minority Migrants in Britain and France: Integration Trade-Offs. New York:: Cambridge Univ. Press
    [Google Scholar]
  76. McAdams RH. 2000.. An attitudinal theory of expressive law. . Or. Law Rev. 79::339
    [Google Scholar]
  77. National Academies of Sciences & Medicine. 2015.. The Integration of Immigrants into American Society. Washington, DC:: Natl. Acad. Press
    [Google Scholar]
  78. Neureiter M. 2019.. Evaluating the effects of immigrant integration policies in Western Europe using a difference-in-differences approach. . J. Ethnic Migr. Stud. 45:(15):2779800
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  79. Neureiter M. 2022.. The effect of immigrant integration policies on public immigration attitudes: evidence from a survey experiment in the United Kingdom. . Int. Migr. Rev. 56:(4):104068
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  80. North DC. 2019.. Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance. New York:: Cambridge Univ. Press
    [Google Scholar]
  81. Pan Y. 2012.. The impact of legal status on immigrants’ earnings and human capital: evidence from the IRCA 1986. . J. Labor Res. 33::11942
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  82. Pantoja AD, Ramirez R, Segura GM. 2001.. Citizens by choice, voters by necessity: patterns in political mobilization by naturalized Latinos. . Political Res. Q. 54:(1):72950
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  83. Pope NG. 2016.. The effects of DACAmentation: the impact of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals on unauthorized immigrants. . J. Public Econ. 143::98114
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  84. Rosholm M, Vejlin R. 2010.. Reducing income transfers to refugee immigrants: Does start-help help you start?. Labour Econ. 17:(1):25875
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  85. Sarvimäki M, Hämäläinen K. 2016.. Integrating immigrants: the impact of restructuring active labor market programs. . J. Labor Econ. 34:(2):479508
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  86. Schildkraut DJ. 2005.. The rise and fall of political engagement among Latinos: the role of identity and perceptions of discrimination. . Political Behav. 27::285312
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  87. Slavin RE, Madden N, Calderón M, Chamberlain A, Hennessy M. 2011.. Reading and language outcomes of a multiyear randomized evaluation of transitional bilingual education. . Educ. Eval. Policy Anal. 33:(2):4758
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  88. Slotwinski M, Stutzer A. 2019.. The deterrent effect of an anti-minaret vote on foreigners’ location choices. . J. Popul. Econ. 32:(3):104395
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  89. Sobolewska M, Galandini S, Lessard-Phillips L. 2017.. The public view of immigrant integration: multidimensional and consensual. Evidence from survey experiments in the UK and the Netherlands. . J. Ethnic Migr. Stud. 43:(1):5879
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  90. Swartz JJ, Hainmueller J, Lawrence D, Rodriguez MI. 2017.. Expanding prenatal care to unauthorized immigrant women and the effects on infant health. . Obstet. Gynecol. 130:(5):93845
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  91. Swartz JJ, Hainmueller J, Lawrence D, Rodriguez MI. 2019.. Oregon's expansion of prenatal care improved utilization among immigrant women. . Matern. Child Health J. 23::17382
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  92. Unutulmaz KO. 2019.. Turkey's education policies towards Syrian refugees: a macro-level analysis. . Int. Migr. 57:(2):23552
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  93. Van Hook J. 2003.. Welfare reform's chilling effects on noncitizens: changes in noncitizen welfare recipiency or shifts in citizenship status?. Soc. Sci. Q. 84:(3):61331
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  94. Venkataramani AS, Shah SJ, O'Brien R, Kawachi I, Tsai AC. 2017.. Health consequences of the US Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) immigration programme: a quasi-experimental study. . Lancet Public Health 2:(4):e175e181
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  95. Vernby K, Dancygier R. 2019.. Can immigrants counteract employer discrimination? A factorial field experiment reveals the immutability of ethnic hierarchies. . PLOS ONE 14:(7):e0218044
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
  96. Wilke A, Humphreys M. 2020.. Field experiments, theory, and external validity. . In The SAGE Handbook of Research Methods in Political Science and International Relations, 2:, L Curini, R Franzese, 100735. London:: SAGE
    [Google Scholar]
  97. Williamson AF. 2018.. Welcoming New Americans? Local Governments and Immigrant Incorporation. Chicago:: Univ. Chicago Press
    [Google Scholar]
  98. Wright M, Bloemraad I. 2012.. Is there a trade-off between multiculturalism and socio-political integration? Policy regimes and immigrant incorporation in comparative perspective. . Perspect. Politics 10:(1):7795
    [Crossref] [Google Scholar]
/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-polisci-051921-102651
Loading

Supplemental Materials

  • Article Type: Review Article
This is a required field
Please enter a valid email address
Approval was a Success
Invalid data
An Error Occurred
Approval was partially successful, following selected items could not be processed due to error